preview

Compare And Contrast Biological And Sociocultural Theories

Decent Essays
Open Document

The nature versus nurture debate is one that has long been argued .The nature theory argues that behaviours are passed on in genes.In contrast nurture theorists believe cultural and social issues affect behaviour. The attachments between infants and caregivers can be studied to evaluate this argument. Oxforddictionaries.com (2015), defines attachment as 'An extra part or extension that is or may be attached to something to perform a particular function'. This essay will compare and contrast biological and sociocultural theories surrounding attachment. The biological theory suggests genes, brain structure and hormones are all responsible for behaviour. John Bowlby's theory proposed that babies have an innate need to form a monotonous attachment, one that evolved from the need for survival. Based on a study of imprinting, carried out by Lorenz(1935). Lorenz observed that geese imprinted on, and followed, the first moving object they saw. The consequence being an innate need for survival and protection. Imprinting happened as early as 1 hour after hatching and Lorenz believed that once imprinting occurred it could not be transposed. This study implied that attachment is genetically programmed. …show more content…

(Introduction to Psychology, 2015) A key, cultural study by Margaret Mead (1953) ads credence to Vygotsky's theory. Mead investigated gender identity within 3 tribal communities and compared them to those in Western cultures. The study concluded that cultural factors did indeed influence gender identity. The question as to whether these cultural differences would reflect in attachment, was answered positively in a study by Van Ijzendoorn and Kroonenberg

Get Access