preview

Compare And Contrast Father Son Relationships In Swimming Downstream

Decent Essays

Swimming upstream directed by Russell Mulcahy as a 2003 film and shine directed by Scott Hicks in 1996 were both inspiring award winning films. Shine tells the story of a famous pianist David Helfgott and how he was challenged by his father’s arrogance. Swimming upstream tells the story about an Australian swimmer, Tony Fingleton, and how he had to conquer the bad relationship that he had with his father to achieve success. They are both based on true stories that emphasize father son relationships and also are both told in the perspective of the son. Both main characters are very talented and in pursuit of their ultimate goals.
They are both very different films but both contain very alike element, for instance the theme of father son relationships. In shine David had to overcome his arrogant father to achieve greatness which resulted in him having a major breakdown putting him in a mental institution. His father’s (Peter) personality is completely opposite to David. He is overriding, confident and forceful rather than timid and uncertain. He is extremely firm this is evident in the film where he says, “David, always win. Always win.” David’s father did not want David to leave when he received an acceptance letter to an American university he tossed it into the fire but luckily David was able to escape to accept a second offer, in London, after facing a brutal beating. Peter’s parenting is directly accountable for David’s breakdown in London as it links with David’s past, where he always strived to learn it to impress his father. David was destroyed by the feelings the masterpiece of music released resulting in a breakdown. In swimming upstream Tony’s relationship with his father (Harold) was very one sided, as all Tony wanted was his father’s love. Harold only started taking interest in him when he found out that Tony and his brother John were talented swimmers. Tony and his family had to put up with their drunk, violent and cruel father and to try win his father’s love he attempted to become a champion swimmer. Both Tony and his brother John were both exceptionally good swimmers so they endured hard trainings from their father until they became state champions. So Tony tried extremely hard and eventually

Get Access