Compare And Contrast The Articles Of Confederation Dbq

The Constitution was created to interchange the failing Articles of Confederation. At the top of the American Revolutionary War, the founders had created the Articles of Confederation as a technique to permit states to stay their individual powers whereas still gaining of the good thing about being a part of a bigger entity. The Articles had gone as a result on March one, 1781. However, by 1787 it became apparent that they weren't viable within the future. This particularly became clear once, in 1786, Shay's Rebellion

This compromise allowed both large and small states to agree to the Constitution without actually diminishing their power in Congress. The less-populated states wanted a Congress which had equal representation from all states, on the other hand, the states with large population, such as Virginia, wanted a Congress with representation equivalent to the amount of citizens in each state. Then, Connecticut proposed a Congress with a House of Representatives based on population and a Senate with two members from each state, regardless of its population. The Three Fifths Compromise established the way in which slaves would be counted toward representation in the House of Representatives. “..which shall be determined by adding to the whole number of free persons, including those bound to service for a term of years, excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other persons.. (Document 5)” This compromise settled the conflict between the Northern and Southern states over population. The Northern states thought that slaves shouldn’t be counted and the Southern states believed that they should be counted. Eventually, they both agreed to The Three Fifths

One of the biggest weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation was not having the ability of levy taxes on the states, and having to make requests to state legislators when they needed troops and taxes. In other words, the Confederation gave Congress the power to conduct wars and issue money, but

Some examples of flaws in the Articles of Confederation are that it allows for each state and the federal government to each have their own currency. This is a very big error, considering that a lot of people were merchants at the time and they need to be able to sell goods in other states, because they usually sell for the most. This would bankrupt most merchants and throw the colonies into more debt. Another flaw in the Articles of

The Articles of Confederation could not establish proper legislation, because it had no power of national taxation where it could not properly raise money through taxes, lacked commerce regulation where

The United States ran under two important documents. The first, was the Articles of Confederation, it was ratified in Maryland and it was on effect on March 1, 1781. The second, was the Constitution. The Constitution replaced the Articles of Confederation, when it was ratified on June 21, 1788 in New Hampshire.

To understand what the benefits and drawbacks  were, it is important to compare and contrast the positions in which the documents differ. I believe that they are thus:

One of the weaknesses was that Congress had no money or power or over the state governments or its citizens. Congress had to rely on the state governments to give it money, but the states refused to pay. The citizens themselves could ignore Congress and there was nothing that could be done by the national government and Congress had no power to get money. Another weakness was that Congress’ lack of power lead it unable to defend Loyalist from prejudice and bias from the states. For the Loyalists, property that was take was not paid back and neither was dept. In addition to the other points mentioned, another weakness has to deal with trade. Foreign countries did not want to trade with America because some citizens did not live up to their trade agreements. Even with trades from state to state, states taxed their goods and made it so the other states did not want to buy their goods. Trading was virtually impossible because of lack of business whether it be with other states or other nations. The Articles of Confederation were America’s first attempt at a constitution that had its ups and downs, but its downs is what helped make the

Recently, a meeting of delegates at Carpenter’s Hall in Philadelphia met together with the purpose of revising The Articles of Confederation. Many important people were present, with the likes of Mr. George Washington, who was elected president of the delegation. A total of fifty-five members were present, and they had many opinions on how our new nation shall be operated, and many others. With many southern delegates threatening to pull out of the Union if slaves were to be set free, one significant issue from the beginning was the issue on how to represent the slave population. As the entire delegation was still traveling to Philadelphia, Mr. James Madison sketched together a plan for a bicameral legislature, which was widely accepted

It is the year of 1787 the people in the new United States realized that the Articles needed to be fixed. The states called a convention where the delegates wrote a completely new plan for government. The new plan became the Constitution. The Constitution, with a few amendments, describes the relationship between the national government and you as a citizen of the United States. I am here to let you know that the new Constitution is better than the Articles of Confederation. You must be thinking why? Well I have an answer for you. The Constitution is better than the Article of Confederation because, the Articles had many weaknesses. The Federal Government created by the Constitution is very powerful. The Articles created a government that

Let’s start out by saying that hands down the Constitution is better than the Articles of Confederation. Now allow me to tell you why. A government was created by the Articles of Confederation. This government gave states too much power. They even had more power than the federal government! Under the Articles, the congress couldn’t collect taxes, which made it even harder to pay the soldiers fighting in the Revolutionary War. States also didn’t have a court system, which meant they didn’t have to follow rules or laws. The constitution created a stronger and more set in stone government. It also created federalism. This made sure that the federal government didn’t gain too much power. This is why we the people should accept the Constitution

Out of all of the weaknesses that the Articles of Confederation the two main weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation and they are that the Articles of Confederation said that the national government did not have the power to tax the people to get money. As well as the government only having one branch of government which is the legislative branch. There are

The postwar question apparently was; expecting that there should be some ongoing conference for the exchange of information and for organizing activities of the sovereign states. Throughout the time of the early republic, some Americans, especially those who promoted a strong central government, voiced strong disapproval with the continental congress. In their view, it gave too much power to the state; also, it deprived the central government of the power to tax, which put the new nation on unreliable financial footing (McMurray, 2016).

The Articles of Confederation were one of the first documents to establish the functions of the national government. The articles, allowed the states to remain independent and the Congress acted as the last resort on appeal of disputes. Between May and September of 1787, The Constitutional Convention took place to discuss the frail central government currently in place. From this convention a federal government was established with a more specific role within the country; this role included powers in conducting relations with foreign governments. The Constitution has served as the basis of the United States Government since 1789. (Milestones: 1784-1800)

There were alot of weaknesses and problems with the Article Of Confederation. The important ones that stood out to me are the ones i'm going to talk about. As we know the 13 states had a vote in the National Congress. The national Congress was denied the power to tax. That means it was cause it not to pay for any navy or army things they needed to defend the United States. We know there was also only one vote per state. It didn't matter the size of course.