preview

Comparing A & P And That Room

Decent Essays
Open Document

The short stories A&P and That Room are both incredible stories; however, when compared side by side, That Room is the overall better story. Updike and Wolff, the authors of each of these stories, are extortionary authors, but when it comes to the overall theme of a story. The theme is the base structure and the message of the story, which should be the main point of a story as to why it should be written then? That Room has an A&P beat in the overall department; nonetheless, a literary element characterization in A&P exceeds that compared to That Room would be the element of characterization. For starters, A&P has much better examples of characterization compared to That Room, despite the Sammy being an unreliable narrator, Updike's usage …show more content…

Sammy describes Stokesie's character pretty well and shows his contrast between him and Stokesie. Nonetheless, That Room uses characterization; however, doesn't use its characterization as much to contribute to its theme in contrast to A&P, but it does contribute to events, "While Eduardo talked, Miguel labored silently beside us, now and then grunting with the weight of a bale" (Wolff 5). While Wolff's usage of characterization is well, in contrast to A&P, A&P's usage of characterization contributes to the overall theme; however, That Room exceeds A&P with the literary element of setting. When it came to setting it was a close call, both That Room and A&P have incredible usage of setting such as A&P's description of the grocery store and That Rooms description of the room; however, That Room takes the cake. Wolff uses his setting to contribute to the theme and symbolism of the room, “That room. …show more content…

And then you hit an icy patch on a turn one sunny March day and the wheel in your hands becomes a joke and you are no more than a spectator to your own dreamy slide toward the verge” (Wolff 8). The theme of That Room has much more of an impact, having its elements complement each other, unlike A&P where the story uses a degree of literary devices, with that being mainly being smiles, “The whole store was like a pinball machine and I didn't know which tunnel they'd come out of.” (Updike 12). The theme of the story is simple, yet relatable with the theme being to not be rebellious because of how cruel the world can be, "My stomach kind of fell as I felt how hard the world was going to be to me hereafter” ends with him learning how unforgiving the world is'' (Updike 32). The theme of That Room has a bigger impact, applying to a larger audience, mentioning how people don't have control over their lives, living and having issues thrown their way. The Room uses symbolism and literary devices to complement this

Get Access