preview

Comparing Brooklyn, By Colm Tobin And Memoirs Of A Woman Doctor '

Good Essays

Women all over the world today grow up and try to find their place. Many of whom struggle with the daunting task of discovering their passions. This idea can be played into the theme of women and their discovery of self. Authors who attempt to capture this theme create novels that are relatable and compelling to all audiences. Both Brooklyn written by Colm Tobin and Memoires of a Woman Doctor written by Nawal El Saadawi display this theme beautifully in their novels. While both novels are set in relatively the same time period, they have two very different settings. Brooklyn was set primarily in Brooklyn, New York while Memoirs of a Woman Doctor is set in Cairo, Egypt. In addition to their different settings, they both portray very different types of women. Saadawi’s work displays a very strong willed feministic character while Tobin’s novel illustrates a timid and easy going woman. By comparing the two, it shows that this theme of self-discovery is universal and can be applied to all women no matter their age, gender, and ethnicity. Both novels display a universal theme that all women, no matter their cultural background, experience similar feelings of uncertainty in themselves.
Traditionally, most women have the pressure to do their duty to the family, either by being the woman they want her to be or by complying with what they ask her to do. The two novels discuss this aspect but in two very different ways. In Memoirs of a Women doctor, our unnamed heroine decides to

Get Access