Comparing Direct Democracy And Representative Democracy

Direct democracy is a form of government in which all laws are created by a general vote of society. This means that political decisions are put forward to the people as they are the ones who are going to be directly affected by the outcome of the decision. An example of direct democracy used occasionally in society is referendums. A referendum is a general vote by the electorate on a single political question which has been referred to them for a direct decision. Within this essay I am going to be arguing whether direct democracy should be used more widely by weighing up the

A direct democracy can only work in a small group, so as a form of government

Direct democracy can be defined as a system of democracy in which citizens participate in the majority of legislation; therefore, granting them political self-determination. A representative democracy (also indirect democracy) is a form of democracy founded on the principle of elected officials representing a group of people. A direct democracy has leaders that are chosen specifically by “The People”. There is no Electoral College, or elected officials, to cast the votes of the people, the people cast their own direct votes.

Two different forms of democracy are representative democracy and direct democracy. Representative democracy is where a set of officials are elected to represent a group of people. In the United States an elected representative would represent a state such as South Dakota. In a direct democracy, there is no middle man but the people represent themselves. Plato possibly the greatest western philosopher took a very interesting take on democracy government. In short he says

Direct democracy is a government in which the people directly elect their officials, and vote on the laws which govern them. When a nation has a representative democracy, the people’s officials are elected to act in their stead (Text Pg. 24). The politicians are empowered by the people to govern and pass laws. A constitutional democracy is one in that the politicians are representatives of the people (Text Pg. 21). The politicians acknowledge that there are limitations on their power, and that the people are sovereign.

Under Representational democracy, elected officials represent a group of people. The people have the ability to elect their leaders. Some laws associated with Representational democracy are flawed. Starting with the voting age, there are biased principles as to what age citizens should have the

Direct democracy means the capacity that people have to vote directly in elections, decision-making and policy-making processes. There are three major forms of direct democracy; initiative, referendum, and recall. The Initiative democracy is known as a process where a public vote can be introduced by a minimum number of registered voters in the ballot while the referendum take place when the legislature present to the voters a constitutional amendment or law proposal before its final approval (plebiscite). On the other hand, recall is a device by which the voters can end or remove an elected official before the conclusion of his/her term.

1). Through these concepts democracy has enhanced the lives of many people throughout the world. It promotes individual liberty and with individual liberty a person is allowed “freedom of expression, freedom of conscience, and freedom to own private property (Lynn-Jones). Representative government is the ideal type of polity, it allows for the improvement of the polity. People are able to engage with their government and are not just passive recipients. The government by design has to respond to the people and promote the public interest. The responsibility is on the people to be attentive, capable of taking action when needed, and to have wise judgement as to the actions of its government

In spite of the fact that the legislature is mandated to create and pass laws on behalf of the state, elements of direct democracy have always acted as constraints. The most famous forms of direct democracy include referendum and initiative (Damore, Bowler, and Nicholson 368). Initiatives are often used to defend the interest of specific groups of citizens. The implication is that instead of the legislature deciding on issues, the citizens are left with the responsibility of determining the fate of certain policies. Initiatives need a particular number of citizens to agree to a petition so that the public can be allowed to vote on the matter in question. It means that if people feel that a certain policy championed by the legislature is not

In a representative democracy is a form of government wherein it’s citizens vote for or elect someone to represent them.

By definition, a representative democracy is a form of government that is chosen to represent a large group of people. After conducting elections, the elected are to proceed with affirmative government actions by fulfilling society’s needs. A representative democracy emphasizes active participation and political interest in order to choose the presumably best fitting elected representative to form decisions on behalf of the greater masses. If citizens do not raise questions or concerns that impact

A Direct Democracy is where the people rule the country themselves. Getting all together and hashing out how their country will be ran. A Representative Democracy is where the people vote on someone to make their decisions for them. Obviously a direct democracy is favorable but when you grow to size of thousands than millions of people it becomes an unrealistic expectation to get everyone to agree to do it one way or another. A representative democracy or a republic is a much more feasible option for highly populated areas. Republics are countries that have no monarch and are governed by the people. (Magleby, D)

Direct Democracy change the way the Athenians lived because they now had a way of changing things with agreements. According to “Athenian Democracy Encyclopedia” most of the voting was done by a couple of people because the people who lived far away could not afford to get there. This

Direct democracy is when the citizens discuss and gather to create a law. Direct democracy is not highly practiced in the United States of America because it requires all the citizens to participate. Representative democracy is when the citizens elect representatives as their voice. Representative democracy is highly used today in the United States to establish the constitution, labor laws, branches of government, and political parties. Thus this paper will feature the American national government national policy, branch government, and constitution. A critical analyzation of the United States Constitution uncovering the strength and weakness of the system. In particular, the controversial issue of the abortion law tremendous effect on the United States Constitution. Additionally, the labor laws established in the United States has a higher disadvantage for employers and employees. The Branch of Government protects the people as well as empowers the president to be an effective leader. As much the impact of the political parties’ success to the checks and balances of the

The purpose of democracy is to allow the majority to express their opinion and have their needs met. Democratic systems of government are separated into direct democracy and representative democracy. Direct democracy is advantageous for the people because each political decision is made by the people. As for representative democracy, the difference lies within the representative's decisions. In a representative democracy, the majority is represented through smaller groups of individuals elected by the people.