preview

Comparing Emerson, Thoreau, Hawthorne, And Melville

Decent Essays

Some of the greatest early American authors were very close in friendship. They lived in the same time frame, shared similar experiences, and even also wanted to accomplish the same goal in their work. But as each man is different in their own right so were these men in how they accomplished that end result. Early American authors like Emerson, Poe, Thoreau, Hawthorne and Melville were exposed to some of the same times in American history, but they kept their individuality in their writing which caused some similarities and differences between them. It is these differences that makes each writer unique in their own right. All five of these early American authors were born after the American Revolution and grew up in similar times, and …show more content…

Poe wrote of death, Emerson and Thoreau fought against slavery, Hawthorne according to George Perkins wrote, “He was absorbed by the enigmas of evil and of moral responsibility, interwoven with human destiny in nature and in eternity; but in this interest he was not unusual as he shared it with such contemporaries as Poe, Emerson, and Melville” (324). These authors felt compelled to break free from the normal standards of writing, and into a new era that was less restrictive where the individualism of a man meant that each man was responsible for his own actions. This individualism is where each of these authors’ differences came into …show more content…

It would not have been right to them to fight for individualism, and then share the same writing style. Emerson’s difference can be seen in his writing “Ode to Beauty” when he writes, “Or what was the service for which I was sold” (7-8). He is talking of slavery, and he incorporates nature and religion into the same poem when he writes, “To hide or shun whom the infinite one hath granted his throne? The heaven high over is the deep’s lover; the sun and sea informed by thee” (34-40). Poe’s individualism is shown in “The Premature Burial” as he writes of people being buried alive, his way of making a statement that stands out (309-18). Thoreau writes in “Walden Visitors” about individualism as they stand in opposition to the general society as he incorporates the love of nature against society (171-79). Hawthorne uses irony as he writes of a traveler who wished to be famous for his life, only to become famous because of his death in “The Ambitious Guest” (328-33). And finally Melville’s differences are shown in “Bartleby, the Scrivener” when he writes about Bartleby who is tired of doing things the way he is told (336-61). He is rebelling against the normal

Get Access