preview

Comparing Journey's End And A Long Way

Better Essays
Open Document

The defining characteristics of WW1 were its sickening violence and its immense death toll so, understandably, many pieces of war literature aim to present the horrors of war in order to unflinchingly reveal the true experiences of the soldiers. However, Journey’s End by R.C Sherriff and A Long Long Way by Sebastian Barry also focus on the emotional aspect of war and the relationships it created and destroyed. The war forced people of every background to rely on and interact with each other while it also wrenched soldiers away from their families, introducing unique tensions between people that would not have existed otherwise. However, it is debatable which form, Sherriff’s play or Barry’s novel, is most effective in presenting these relationships. …show more content…

It could be argued that Journey’s End, being a play, makes the audience feel the same literal detachment from women as the soldiers felt; the single setting means that we only actually encounter the presence of women through the men’s dialogue and Sherriff cannot show the soldiers going home and interacting with their partners. Therefore, the audience can somewhat understand the separation soldiers felt from their families because we, watching the play, do not get to experience their family lives either. In this way, I think the novel form of A Long Long Way is beneficial because Barry, aided by using third-person narration, can present a wider range of relationships during wartime by exploring different settings; even though the novel is centred on Willie, Barry avoids a narrow account of just one person’s experience by not using first-person narration. Therefore, I find that Barry’s novel is better at covering a variety of relationships, while Sherriff’s play presents a more focussed account of trench life and can recreate the detachment from women for the audience. Stanhope, a captain ashamed of his alcoholism and mental state, has added to this separation between couples by refusing to take leave to see his girlfriend Madge and, as Raleigh points out, ‘he doesn’t say much in his letters,’ perhaps to protect her from …show more content…

For example, in A Long Long Way, Christy Moran wishes he was meeting up with ‘some girl’ and thinks about ‘the dress on her, and how clean and good and sweet-smelling and everything, and the neat coats that girls do have.’ The monosyllabic words ‘clean’, ‘good’, ‘sweet’ and ‘neat’ are short and therefore mirror the simplicity of the soldier’s wishes. Additionally, the repeated use of ‘and’ adds to the line’s uncomplicated structure and consequently shows it’s innocent and honest tone; the pure thoughts of being in the comfort of women helps the soldiers block out the surrounding

Get Access