preview

Comparing 'One Art And The Story We Know'

Decent Essays

There are various ways to depict a certain theme, a common way being transmitted through the tone. Two separate poems illustrate the same theme, yet do it through their different respective tones. The villanelles, Elizabeth Bishop’s “One Art” and Martha Collins “The Story We Know” both convey a theme of love and loss; However, Bishop displays an indifferent, self-loathing tone, while Collins portrays a familiar, accepting tone. In “One Art” by Elizabeth Bishop, her use of literary elements help her achieve an attempted detached, nonchalant tone that veils confused internal emotions equating to loss. She brings about this through imagery which is expressed prevalently in this poem. When the speaker describes the person she has lost, “The joking …show more content…

More imagery is abundant in the physical things such as the watch, the house, the cities, and the river. Symbolism is exhibited through the use of art. The speaker focuses on "the art of losing," which she depicts is something where practice makes perfect. However, this isn’t an art necessarily we can ever truly become proficient in. The poem’s ironic command that we "lose something every day" (line 4) to practice getting over the sensation of loss implies that if we lose enough small things,when we lose the bigger or more important ones we will be prepared. No matter how practiced and adept we become at the art of losing, we can never really be ready for the pain of these losses. Those losses will always seem like a “disaster.” The other kind of art in this poem is the poetry itself. The entire poem functions as a coping mechanism for the poet. She forces herself to confront her losses by physically writing them down. There is power in this act of writing, as shown in her last line, in which she forces herself to admit that the loss of her loved one "may look (Write it!) like disaster" (line 19). Line 1 is repeated in both

Get Access