preview

Comparing Otomi's Virginity And Rashomon

Good Essays
Open Document

Author Akutagawa Ryuhusuke wrote both Otomi’s Virginity and Rashomon, allowing similarities between both stories however, the use of the setting, the characters, themes and tone were portrayed differently. Both stories were set in manufactured scenarios but Rashomon’s setting was also natural. In the two stories, they had a samurai and a female character. However, one of the females was a young, attractive maid while in the other story the female character was an old gray-haired hag . Lastly, the stories used a lot of themes and tone. The themes are similar yet very different in the way they were used throughout the story. The type of setting used in Otomi’s Virginity and Rashomon were alike but expressed things differently. As previously …show more content…

The samurai, also known as Shinko, never identify himself as a samurai, only as a beggar, and has no symbols on him that would explain he is a samurai. He never dwells into who he is other than the fact that he is seeking shelter in a house. The revelation that Shinko is indeed a samurai is at the end. Many years later, Otomi sees him again but this time when she sees him sitting in a two horse carriage with many badges of honor, both small and large. From the beginning, it was easy to understand that the main character in Rashomon was a samurai since he had been dismissed by his master, whom he served for many years, because the economy of the city was declining. He was then left with nothing, seeking shelter in the tower. It was then he started to decide whether or not he should become a thief and survive or stay humble and honest but starve to death. The main difference between Shinko and the main character in Rashomon is that Shinko did not let his desire win. Shinko took advantage of the fact that he was armed in an abandoned house with a young maid, he ordered her to go to the living room and strip so he can have his way with her. However, when the time came he didn’t follow through with his actions: “In the middle of the room he found her lying on her back, her face covered with her sleeves. The moment he saw her, he scurried back to the kitchen. His face had a …show more content…

There’s different ways the themes was portrayed in the stories. In Otomi’s Virginity, we can understand Shinko’s state of mind when he’s talking to the cat: “Tomorrow may be an evil day for both you and me. Tomorrow I may die, too. Even if I get off unhurt, I won’t hunt around rubbish heaps any more, and you’ll be mighty happy, won’t you?” Anyone that knows there’s a possibility of them dying because of a war, it will create psychological damage which can lead to them acting out in ways they would never have done if their state of mind was normal. It’s believed that if it weren’t for his psychological state he wouldn’t have insinuated that he was going to rape Otomi. The samurai in Rashomon had a life changing experience in the beginning of the story; his status from a samurai was taken away and was now alone with nowhere to go. There’s a glimpse of his psychological state when he’s debating on whether or not he should stay honest and starve to death or steal and become a thief. He has doubt running around in his mind putting him in a very fragile state of mind which would allow him to be more sensitive than usual towards emotions. His sensitive psychological state could be the reason why he reacted the way he did when he saw the old lady taking the hair off the dead body. Another theme in both stories is the philosophical theme. In Otomi’s Virginity, Shinko starts to question his ethics once he sees Otomi on the

Get Access