preview

Comparing Patriarchy In A Midsummer's Night Dream And King Lear

Better Essays

The basis of the father-familial relationship as plot tension or subject is often similar through literature: the patriarch wants something and the family doesn’t. However, the contrast of this paradigm within the two genres of tragedy and comedy is readily apparent within William Shakespeare’s A Midsummer’s Night Dream and King Lear. The relationships of the characters, most notably women, to their father and lord show the contrasts in the differences of the seriousness and depiction of tragedy and comedy. The most acute examples of this are the relationships between noble, rebellious daughters Hermia and Cordelia and their respective, fathers Egeus and King Lear.
To discuss the ideas associated with rebellion against the patriarchy within …show more content…

His antagonism is not his fault, however. He is a bastard who cannot become Earl of Gloucester’s legitimate heir. Being a bastard leaves him on the outskirts of society; his own father at on the outset of the play crudely discusses his infidelity with Edmund’s mother to Lord Kent, “there was good sport at his making, / and the whoreson must be acknowledged.” His position in society urges him into sin of envy, ambition, lust, and indirect patricide. His brother, Edgar, in comparison has just as many reasons to become a disloyal usurper, as well. His eventual inheritance is jeopardized by his father’s own sins of adultery. Later, after his father has become blinded, Edgar goes to his father, who had banished him previously and tries to comfort him; the earl, however, fails to recognize his own son, showing his overall aloofness. According to Skura, Edgar has too committed sins but they, like Lear’s wife, are indirect, “Edgar may not literally want his father dead. But, like all sons, he wants his father out of the way or at least powerless; he wants his father’s power and place,” (p. 131). This befuddlement of evil, sin, and mistakes typifies the tragic form in contrast to comedic form which ignores or makes light of such events, making them grave mistakes rather than egregious

Get Access