preview

Alice And Barry Face

Decent Essays

What would life be like if people didn't undergo change? Many opportunities happen in life because of adjustments people make for themselves. In the short stories "Mirror Image" by Lena Coakley and "Saturday Climbing" by W.D. Valgardson the protagonists Alice and Barry both have struggles with the major changes happening in their life. Throughout their stories, they become less pessimistic, they adress their problems and they gain a newfound confidence and trust in others. Change can be extremely difficult, but its a necessary step towards a positive life.

In both stories, the protagonists show fear towards changes which are occurring in their lives. Barry from "Saturday Climbing" has a pessimistic attitude about his daughters plans to move away for her post-secondary education. This is because he leads a plain life for them both in order to keep his daughter safe. "He did his best to keep life simple and uncomplicated. It was, he thought, the way to provide her with security" (20). His fear comes from the idea that he will have no way of keeping her safe if she is away, on her own. Alice from "Mirror Image" also has fear and a sense of denial, though this stems from undergoing a brain transplant. While looking in her hand mirror she said to herself "Just you, Alice... …show more content…

When Barry found himself struggling to fully trust his daughter, he reminded himself of a quote a student was told him: "the world seeks balance" (27). He allowed his daughter to become more independant because of that quote, causing their relationship to grow stronger. Alice neeeded validation that she was still herself, though she was in a different body. "I'll tell her I looked into your eyes and that i didn't see my daughter" (6). When Alice saw her body donor's father, he didn't recognize her. This gave her validation that even though she didn't appear the same, she still was her own

Get Access