preview

Comparing The Film 'And Pecos Bill'

Decent Essays
Open Document

Tall Tale Comparison I will be comparing the movie and written versions of a tall tale character and giving some background on tall tales. Tall Tales are stories that are usually 1 to 2 pages long and consist of lots of action and an over-the-top superhero-type protagonist. The tall tale I'll be comparing is “Pecos Bill”. Pecos Bill is a cowboy from Texas. He's best known for his story where he lassoed a tornado and saved a small town. There are many depictions of the character Pecos Bill, but I'll be comparing the Disney movie version and the tall tale version. The version that is truly better is the movie version. The movie and written versions of Pecos Bill have many similarities and differences throughout. Some of the similarities include …show more content…

Now that I've talked about the similarities, we have to talk about the differences as well. The movie, compared to the tall tale story, is definitely better at really showing how much he truly cares about doing the right thing, even if sometimes it doesn't work out how he wants. Another difference from the movie that I thought was pretty interesting was the fact that Pecos Bill was friends with the other tall tale characters like Paul Bunyan and John Henry. In the written version, they didn’t mention any other characters or the fact that they knew each other. In my opinion, the film version of ‘Pecos Bill” is better than the written story. The film adaptation of Pecos Bill displays the character and his ideals way better than the tall tale stories, like his passion to keep people safe. The movie also does a really good job of showing unrealistic tall tale stories visually. The way the characters are dressed and their mannerisms are way more clear. Pecos Bill is displayed much better in the movie version compared to the written version. The movie has a great way of showing what kind of person he is and the unrealistic nature of the situations he gets himself

Get Access