preview

Comparing The Head Vs. Heart In The Road, By Cormac Mccarthy

Decent Essays

As humans, there is a constant internal struggle as to whether we should guide our lives through reason or emotion. Another approach to this question would be to ask: should we follow our head or heart? Personally, I wish I could say that I listen to the more logical approaches in my head, but I tend to follow my emotions to solve situations. The whole idea of “head versus heart” questions whether we follow what’s morally right in situations or if we take the most realistic approach. Back in ancient Greece, Plato was one of the first philosophers to claim how our head is “the source of rational wisdom, whereas the heart is the source of the passions” (Fetterman and Robinson). By this statement, our head is viewed as the more logical reasoning to situations while our heart is centered around our ethics. As a compassionate person, I tend to see the better in people, hoping that others share the same compassion that I hold in myself. However, I …show more content…

For example, in the novel The Road by Cormac McCarthy, a young man and his son dispute about whether to kill a dog in a post-apocalyptic world when the boy asks “we’re not going to kill it, are we Papa?” (McCarthy 82). This scene displays the conflict between choosing the more logical approach, which would be to kill the dog for food, or to let the dog roam free and spare his life, which would be the more ethical response. In this example, the young boy is the one that asks to spare the dog's life while the man views the dog as a reliable food source. This can also further the theory that as the older we get, the more logical and less compassionate we tend to be. The young boy in this novel does not want to kill the dog because he sees this as inhumane, while as we grow older our maturity and wisdom is more reasonable, like the man’s idea to kill the dog. Personally, in this situation, I would have followed my emotions and spare the dog’s

Get Access