preview

Comparing The New Science Of Leading Change And The Three Signs Of A Miserable Job

Decent Essays

Those who aspire to be good leaders need information and knowledge to guide their employees to greatness. The Influencer: The New Science of Leading Change and The Three Signs of a Miserable Job have a wealth of information for leaders as well as their employees to expand their lives and the way they live it. This paper will compare and contrast the New Science of Leading Change and The Three Signs of a Miserable Job to show the importance of both books. Additionally, it will give the rationale behind using the two books in the same course. Lastly, it will outline how a leader can learn from and use the information in the two books to create a more effective organizational environment.
COMPARING THE TWO LEADERSHIP BOOKS When comparing …show more content…

The Influencer starts by asking the questions, “Can I do what’s required? and Am I Motivated?” This starting point allows the influencer to assess whether the six-source model will be beneficial to the employees. On the other hand, the Three Signs model aspire leaders to engage their employees; therefore, benefitting the organization to build a culture of job fulfillment. This book asks managers to take a self-assessment, relating to anonymity, irrelevance and immeasurement. The Three Signs of a Miserable Job (2007) boasts the first step to reducing job misery lies in understanding the root causes of a miserable job (p. 220). Comparing the two books shows the benefits to leaders and their employees. Contrasting the two books will display noticeable differences in achieving their goals.
CONTRASTING THE TWO BOOKS In contrast to The Three Signs of a Miserable Job, the Influencer summarizes three mistakes which can be made during the six-source model. These mistakes include: fuzzy, uncompelling goals, infrequent or no measures, and bad measures. These mistakes according to the Influencer (2013) can undermine the influence of the change agents; therefore, allowing no vital behavior change to happen (p. 16). Due to this factor, The Three Sign of a Miserable Job does not give steps to follow when their model

Get Access