preview

Comparison Of Andrew Jackson And The Battle Of New Orleans

Decent Essays

(Discredit) (Intro) Stories such as theses are fantastic tall tale, but it is not a true representation of the real tale. (DS) This tale exaggerated a great deal about the details of the battle. Not to mention that it is also a one-sided story that makes it feel as if the Americans lost barely any men. Furthermore, this story also brings a relatively unrealistic view of the military, as if they were a tangled grove of unkempt trees with many species (Dendrographia). (TH) Truly, these are just a few of the reasons I will refute “Andrew Jackson and the Battle of New Orleans,” and disorganized scrap of fiction. (Exposition) (NR) When the British marched into the south, Maurice Thompson said that Jackson was the only man who could defeat them. …show more content…

(ST) Even if Jackson was the only one who could save the day, it is not likely that the outnumbered, out skilled Americans could be victorious over the monstrous British. (RQ) Does winning come so easily for untrained soldiers? (CA) Someone might say, “It was the American spirit that helped them win.” (ACA) However one might retort, “But the British, who had just beaten the French, would have high in spirit similarly. ” (DL) Consequently, either the British did not think that defeating the French was something to be proud of, or this never happened. (CA) “The Americans had the upper hand, for they had the barracks.” Another might argue. (DL) In conclusion either the Redcoats had never been trained to win battles that seemed to not bend in their favor, or they won the battle. (ST) It is unlikely that the Americans defeated the Lobsterbacks. (Impossibility) (TR) Let us say that the vastly outnumbered Americans defeated their foes, (RQ) why would the British infantry march out in the open? (GT) It is quite impossible that a general would risk the lives of his militia by bringing them out into the open. (RQ) If a grand, highly decorated general of war was known for demolishing large French armies with ease, then how could he and his men loose to a motley mob of soldiers? (ST)

Get Access