Comparison of the Two Speeches in Julius Caesar Essays

Mark Antony says, “Yet Brutus says he [Caesar] was ambitious.” This quote was used a grand total of three times in act 1 scene 2 on lines 95, 107, and 102. This excerpt is used to show that Caesar was not determined to take the crown and rule Rome. Each time this quote was used, Antony gave examples of how Caesar really wasn’t ambitious, such as when he says, “I thrice presented him the kingly crown, which he did thrice refuse” (3.2.105-106). This quote shows that if Caesar really was ambitious, then he would have taken the crown and become king, but instead he refused. Not only did he refuse once, but three times. These examples shows many examples as to why Caesar was not ambitious did not want to be king. Antony repeats the phrase, “And Brutus is an honorable man.” This quote was repeated in act one scene two in lines 96, 103, and 108. Each time this quote is said, Antony had recently described why Brutus is honorable, such as when he says, “He hath brought many captives home to Rome” (3.2.97). This quote paints Brutus as a hero for bringing Roman people held in foreign lands home. The quote also brings to question Brutus’s own motives, questioning if he performed these gallant acts because he himself is ambitious. The quote also questions why Brutus conspired against his best friend if he is so honorable. Antony talks a lot about “Honorable men” or “Honorable man.” He uses the quotes for a collective total of seven times. The quotes are used in act one scene two in lines 91, 92, 103, 108, 136, 149, 163. Antony was given a set of specific rules before giving his speech, one of which was that he can not talk bad about the conspirators. Antony uses the word honorable to make it seem as though the truthful and possibly bad things he says about the conspirators was not as bad since they were still honorable, but none the less, Antony got

During his speech he asks,”I thrice presented him a kingly crown, Which he did thrice refuse: was this ambition?”( lll.ii.24-25). Then he answers his own question by saying,” Yet Brutus says he was ambitious; And, sure, he is an honourable man. I speak not to disprove what Brutus spoke, But here I am to speak what I do know.”(lll.ii.23-29). Antony uses this rhetorical question to make the people question Brutus and his honesty, although he states this isn’t his intention. If Caesar was really so power hungry, then why did he refuse the crown? This is the question he wants the listeners to think about. He is trying to make Brutus sound selfish while also protecting

At Caesar’s funeral, Brutus and Antony give their speeches. Antony uses pathos in his speech to get to the crowd’s emotions so they will relate to his side of the speech. Brutus tries to use logos in his speech so that the crowd will be on his side. Brutus also used a little bit of ethos in his speech. If a writer knows how to read their audience, it will make persuading his audience a lot easier.

But even though Antony arrived seeing Caesar’s bloodied body on the floor in front of him, he went with the flow and easily fooled Brutus into allowing him to speak on the platform right after his speech was done. (III.3.12-44) “Be patient till… need my death.” Brutus claimed that leaving Caesar alive would have been the biggest mistake for Rome and that if he were still alive, they would all be slaves until the end of their own lives. He claims that only because he was going with what he thought was just and partially because of how the main conspirators managed to manipulate him in a way. But as the people rejoice and start to make judgments saying Brutus should be the new Caesar of Rome, he calms them down and tells them to remain with Antony to pay their respects to Caesar’s death. And with that, Antony’s famous speech begins. (III.2.71-105) “Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears… come back to me.” Within Antony’s speech, there’re slight hints of his disagreement to Brutus’s claims of Caesar being “ambitious” which mostly every person listening to Antony’s speech heard or understood. He explained that everything about Caesar being ambitious is true… only according to Brutus, the honorable man that would not lie to the people of Rome. But as he’s saying that,

The speech began using strong Logos, specifically Faulty Syllogism. Antony starts by stating that, “Brutus is an honorable man; So are they all, all honorable men,” (I.ii. 78-79) and that whatever this honorable man says must be true. Except, he says it all very ironically. “[Caesar] was my friend, faithful and just to me; But Brutus says he was ambitious, and Brutus is an honorable man.” (I.ii. 82-84) And if he is so honorable, then why would he lie, except to cover up what they did. Antony continues to tell the people these caring things Caesar had done, and following it by asking them, “Did this in Caesar seem ambitious?”(I.ii.87) As said in Joseph Romm’s book Language Intelligence, “Repetition, the re-experiencing of something identical, is clearly in itself a source of pleasure,”(Romm, 29). So by using repetition, he

In Antony speech he goes on and says "When that the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept: Ambition should be made of sterner stuff. Yet Brutus says he was ambitious still ". This is said because in Brutus speech he Calls Caesar ambitious. This confuse Antony after that Antony says "I thrice presented him a kingly crown, Which he did thrice refuse, was this ambition"?He says this so that he can prove to the people that he is not but Brutus still calls out and says yes he his. Antony keeps going and stats that "You all did love him once, not without cause". He says this because he wants to show the citizens how they are just using judgement. This is because they have lost their reason.

Antony references Brutus’ speech and how Brutus claims Caesar was an ambitious man. Antony mentions that when “the poor have cried, Caesar hath wept” and that Antony “thrice presented him a kingly crown, Which he did thrice refuse.” By participating in these actions of weeping and refusing a higher position, it is made clear that Caesar was not ambitious as Brutus made the audience believe. By providing examples of how Caesar was ambitious and repeating the messages of Brutus stating the opposite, it is made clear to the audience that Brutus is untrustworthy. Mark Antony also expresses his ideas regarding Brutus by ironically using the term “honourable man.” Antony believes that Brutus is a corrupt man. He helped murder his friend Caesar and then spoke to the people of Rome about how he believed it was the right thing to do. In Rome, Brutus is considered noble and honorable. In Mark Antony’s speech, he repeats errors that Brutus made and follows them with “Brutus is an honourable man.” As Antony proves that Caesar was unambitious, he repeats “Yet Brutus says he was ambitious; And Brutus is an honourable man.” He does this to undermine the trust that the people have in Brutus and to strengthen the faith they have in him. By using these methods and utilizing repetition and irony, Mark Antony is able to reverse the preconceived notion conveyed by Brutus, which

Brutus speech permanently fails to successfully win the people over because he does not appreciate or understand them. Largely his failure starts at the beginning when asking the people to, “Censure me in your wisdom, and wake your senses” (III. Ii. 17-18). His failure to realize that the people are an angry mob and wisdom is lacking due to the shared anger. His argument is delivered coldly and with calculating reasoning. His argument of

Antony addresses the crowd by using Brutus’ words and actions against his explanation, by citing Caesars actions and deeds to appeal to the crowd’s heart. Brutus states in his speech that Caesar is ambitious and “his ambition-for that, I killed him.” (III.ii.25-26). Antony disproves that Caesar is ambitious by using many facts. For example, after sharing that Caesar “was my friend [and] faithful just to me.” (III.ii.83), he lists many things that Caesar did. Some facts he uses to disprove Brutus include, “He brought many captives home to Rome whose ransoms brought wealth to the city. When the poor cried, Caesar cried too. I offered him the king’s crown three times, and he refused it three times. Is this the work of an ambitious man?” (III.ii.87-88). During his speech, Antony asks the crowds permission to step down and join them in the street. He doesn 't use his position in the Senate to stand above them, but rather he reminds them that he is one of them. A Roman citizen. Antony also describes Brutus as “an honorable man” (III.ii.80), but are these the actions of a man who

Unlike Brutus’ prose speech, Mark Antony’s speech is in blank verse, which is used in more passionate writing. Antony’s speech subtly disproves Brutus while heightening the crowd’s emotions to rage. Antony mentions times in which Caesar’s actions did not portray ambition, and then following each example, he says, “Yet Brutus says he was ambitious, / and Brutus is an honorable man” (86-88, 93-94, 98-99). This use of epimone subtly disproves Brutus, and starts to turn the crowd against him, because it not only shows Brutus in bad light, but also makes it seem like the people conclude this on their own, even though Antony’s manipulations are very much at play. Antony appeals to pathos when he addresses the crowd, saying: “hearing the will of Caesar, / It will inflame you; it will make you mad” (3.2.42-43). He then uses paralipsis when he “o’ersho[o]t[s] [him]self” (150) by saying “‘Tis good you know not that you are his heirs” (line 145), which escalates the crowd’s love for Caesar and hatred toward his assassinators: “[The conspirators] were villains, murderers!”(155). To heighten the rage against the conspirators even more, Antony shows the crowd of plebeians Caesar’s dead body, and Caesar’s famous cloak now run through by knives: “Look, in this place ran Cassius’ dagger through. / See what a rent the envious Casca made. / Through this the well-belovèd Brutus stabbed” (172-175). By mentioning the conspirators’ names, Antony creates a hatred of those men and their followers. Also, by showing the crowd Caesar’s cloak, which he obtained after conquering a tribe, Antony reminds the crowd both how great Caesar was and how horribly wrong it was that his greatness was shredded by the knives of traitors. Antony continues his expression of Caesar’s

There are two speeches that are very well remembered from Shakespeare's play Julius Caesar, those speeches came from Brutus and the other came from Antony. They both talk about the death of Caesar, but one has more power to persuade than the other. Brutus and Antony were both very good orators. They both persuaded crowd, but which one persuaded the crowd better is the real question.

John C. Maxwell once said, “People hear your words, but feel your attitude.” This is relevant to Antony’s speech because he used his attitude combined with his words to sway the Roman people. Brutus and Antony’s speeches had similarities, but the differences in the type of rhetoric gave Antony control over the people. By using logos and ethos, Brutus tried to persuade the people toward believing his innocence. Contrarily, Antony effectively rallied the crowd into an unruly mob with heavy pathos. While Brutus’ speech could have been effective on its own and Antony's speech won the people to his side, both speeches had fallacies that the common people did not recognize.

In Brutus's speech, he told the people to believe him for his honor. He doesn't give them reasons to believe him. Brutus goes on to say that Caesar was ambitious but again never gives reasons for this statement. This left the people with many questions. Brutus's speech

The speech given by Brutus is very much dependent on his appeal to the peoples desire to be loyal to Rome. He even calls them "Romans" and then he calls them "countrymen"(3.2,1390). This indicates that he values allegiance to the country and not becoming to attached to the things and the people in life. Brutus tries to get the people on his side by saying that Caesar was ambitious and that he was power hungry. By calling Caesar a tyrant, Brutus conveys to the people of Rome that loyalty to country is more important than any person, figure, or even close friend.

However, Antony understood the audience better, he knew that he could manipulate the people if he used the correct rhetoric. He started off by saying he was only there to bury Caesar and made it clear that he thought Brutus is a honorable and noble man. After that, Antony moves on and gets to his point. Later in the speech he showed that Caesar might not have been as ambitious as Brutus thought, he brings up how Caesar did not accept the crown. Antony acted like he respected Brutus because the people did, but really he was undermining Brutus and trying to turn the people against the conspirators.