preview

Conniff's Argument Analysis

Decent Essays
Open Document

Conniff presents a main argument to us with sub-arguments to support it. However, the personal story with Lucky, examples and other background information that are irrelevant to the argument are not included.
Main-argument conclusion: (1) Outdoor cats are becoming socially unacceptable.
Premises for (1): (2) Outdoor cats bear a significant share of the blame for the decline in in wildlife, and especially bird, populations. (3) Outdoor cats threaten the health of human. (4) There are multiple hazards of outdoor living that are terrible for cats.
Sub-argument conclusion: (2)
Premises for (2):
(2a) The numbers of 20 common North American bird species have dropped by 68 percent on average since 1967, due to variety of factors. (2b-Suppressed) …show more content…

This suggested some people are still believing cats are socially acceptable. This argument is weak as even if all the premises is true and the outdoor cats can still be socially acceptable. (2) says cats is significantly blamed for decline in wildlife, however, there are many other factors that plays a significant role in the decline in wildlife compared to cats such as habitat destruction. Also, the decline is bird population is due to cats doing what “natural” for them, like human also eats meats. This suggested cats should not be considered socially unacceptable. Premise (3) is plausible because cats can potential carry disease from outside and bring it back and infect humans. However, if human takes good care of their cats, cure their cats immediately when they are found to be infected with diseases then humans cannot be affected. (4) is plausible because outdoor cats can get various of disease from outdoors as well as a chance of being killed by other animals. However, if cat owners supervise their cats when they go outdoors, then their cats can prevented from getting infected from diseases and preventing injury or death from hazardous outdoor living. As a result, this argument’s weakness makes it a bad

Get Access