preview

Controversies And Criticisms Of Stone's Work

Decent Essays
Open Document

Controversies and Criticisms of Stone’s Work
All of Stone’s films have attracted quite a lot of criticism. As a matter of fact, the film ‘JFK’ was criticized as early as six months prior to its release, in almost all types of print and broadcast. Perhaps it is the film’s questioning of several key institutions in the US, especially the Warren Commission that directed media hostility towards Stone’s JFK (Howard, p. 11). The main purpose of the criticisms and attacks on Stone’s works was to attract and maintain adequate public support and sympathy for institutional powers that supported the Vietnam War. However, the attacks adopted a form that claimed the films have grave historical inaccuracies. Although some of these criticisms are valid, others …show more content…

For instance, the JFK assassination was full of ambiguous and disputed evidence (Howard, p. 11). For an illustration, Lee Harvey Oswald was accused of attempting to kill General Edwin Walker, a fact which may have been true or false. However, there was no definitive evidence to support his having done so or not. If he shot at Walker, that does not prove that he shot at Kennedy; and if he never shot at Walker that does not prove that he did not shoot at Kennedy. Since the movie focuses on Jim Garrison’s investigation of the New Orleans elements of the crime, a good deal of the film’s material falls into this category. Some of the accusations have been confirmed as accurate and point to factual errors in the film. On the other hand, some accusations referred to evidence that could be interpreted in different …show more content…

According to Stephen Rosenfeld of the Washington Post, from Stone’s JKF, the claim that the assassination of JFK most likely involved more than a lone gunman now seems further than a mere grumble (Howard, p. 11). Some critics later started to agree with Stone’s thesis about Vietnam and JFK assassination, stating that if there was more than a gunman, then there was some kind of a conspiracy and the Warren Commission was

Get Access