When one examines the general structure of Anouilh's drama, one is surprised to see how closely he has followed the original. The only scene of Sophocles drama, which Anouilh has dropped completely, is the Tiresias scene. Perhaps it was difficult to introduce the theme of divination in a modern drama, but there is also another reason. In Sophocles Creon finally repents after the departure of Tiresias but Anouilh's Creon does not - indeed, cannot - repent; thus a Tiresias scene would have served no purpose.
Another interesting structural difference is in the Chorus, an element of ancient drama which a modern dramatist finds very difficult to use. Anouilh has not made this attempt, and has kept only one actor whom he still calls the Chorus. This actor in a kind of prologue introduces the characters to us and gives a few facts necessary for the understanding of the plot; at one stage he explains the author's views on the nature of tragedy. He also speaks a few times to Creon in the course of the drama. Thus, in Anouilh's play the chorus serves as more of a narrator, rather than a character.
But naturally the great difference between the two dramas does not lie in the general structure but in the contents of each
…show more content…
Anouilh begins his drama quite differently: Antigone is caught by the Nurse while stealing back into the house after having buried the body. The Nurse accuses her of having gone out to meet a lover, hue she manages to soothe her without telling her the truth. Then Ismene enters and the two sisters discuss the advisability of burying the body. After another conversation between Antigone and the Nurse Haemon appears. In a passionate scene Antigone first reassures herself that he really loves her, and then she tells him that she can never marry
The beginning of the play begins with Antigone and her sister, Ismene. Antigone presents her plan of burying their brother, Polynices, whose body had been denied a proper burial by their uncle, King Creon, since in his eyes Polynices had been seen as an enemy to the city. Antigone wanted Ismene to accompany her, but Ismene immediately refused in fear of the consequences. Ismene states “We are women and we do not fight with men/ We are subject to them
In the Anouilh's version the viewer notices right away that the chorus is only made up of one man instead of many it is also noticeable throughout the movie that the chorus is very active unlike the book where the chorus does not play as much of a role. Although, the chorus still serves the main purpose of being the voice of reason in the story. Another difference in the characters is how in the book the love between Antigone and Haemon is not displayed as much as it was in the movie. In addition, during the movie Anouilh adds an extra scene where Haemon and Antigone develop their relationship, this shows the love between them that is not represented in the book. Another altered scene is that in the book when Antigone is found burying the body Creon sentences her to death instantly, he doesn’t hesitate because of Antigone’s and Haemon's relationship.
Lastly, Antigone recognizes her tragic flaw. In scene four she proclaims "To me, since it was my hand that washed and clean and poured the ritual wine: and my reward it's dead before my time." This quote shows how she not only realizes that it was her own doing that caused her demise but also takes responsibility for it. However, once Antigone realizes her flaw it is too late. Creon had already sentenced her and by the time he changed his mind she had already killed herself. Antigone lost everything because of her
In the play, when Antigone gets caught and conversates with Creon she illustrates, “I would never think your pronouncements had such strength that, being mortal, they could override the unwritten, ever-lasting prescriptions of the gods” (Sophocles
The objective of this study is to examine the importance of not sharing patient information through social media. According to the work of Adler (2011) many physicians are violating HIPAA and do not know it. Dimick (2010) writes that nurses at the Fargo, ND-based healthcare system in 2008 were using Facebook to "provide unauthorized shift change updates to their co-workers. What once would have been a conversation became an update on their personal Facebook pages. It was a convenient tool, because the nurses had "friended" each other through Facebook and thus could quickly read what each other wrote on their pages. They did not use patient names, but they did post enough specifics about patients so that the incoming nurses could prepare for their shift. The problem was that everyone else "friended" to their Facebook pages could also read the information." (p.1) The use of social media to talk about work "sharing sensitive patient or proprietary business information that same easy use and powerful reach broadcasts guarded information to large numbers of people." (Dimick, 2010, p.1) Release of information that is sensitive over social media can result in great harm to the reputation of an organization, violations of HIPAWA and ultimately result in "breach notifications and hefty fines." (Dimick, 2010, p.2) Dimick writes that Kaiser Permanente published "an organization-wide social media policy that explains appropriate staff
Even after she has performed this deed, Antigone’s personality remains the same. She does not show any change whatsoever when she was punished. Until the end of her life, the readers have no clue on what she
“Take me and kill me, what more do you want”(565) “there’s nothing in your words that I enjoy may that always be the case”(567-568) Antigone tells Creon. The conflict between Antigone and Creon cause the characteristics of anger,disrespect, and stubbornness to show up in Creon throughout the play. Only Antigone brings this out in him through her actions,ideas, and words. Overall these conflict motivations make Creon a tragic hero by him thinking he knows what’s best and only following the rules of man and ultimately killing his son and wife. The character interactions advance the plot because both antigone and Creon have such a strong perspective on what they think is right that he causes them to equally make decisions based on their thought of what’s good and what’s not
In Antigone, Creon’s mind is pulled in two opposite directions: His hubris, and, in contrast, his human duty to the gods. His decision to not follow the gods’ decrees and the consequences of that decision are used by Sophocles to remind the audience to stand with the gods.
Through looking at the history of the era, the intentions of the playwright, and the critical analysis and commentary offered on the play, it is in my opinion that Sophocles intended Creon to be the character who was in the right, not Antigone.
While the characters, especially Jason and Medea, do not acknowledge divine forces as potent elements shaping their actions, they are keenly aware of their recurring roles throughout literary history. They force the reader to make a more substantial connection or comparison with the previous work. One might try to recast the earlier analogy, replacing the Greek gods with Anouilh. The characters are his tools, his puppets. This, however, is too simplistic. Anouilh himself must acknowledge the limits of the tale, not simply the sequence of events, but themes and ideas within it, if he is to retell it. In this sense Anouilh is confined and he makes the reader aware of this fact. Within these self imposed limits, though, Anouilh is free to revise, review, elucidate, and articulate the ideas, actions, and opinions of each character.
The death of Antigone is truly a tragic episode in the Theban Plays, where she hung herself with a woven linen of her dress. By convention, her death would be characterized with feminine quality. However, Antigone, one of the few female characters in the book, possessed distinguishable female characteristics that are as remarkable as a male hero. Antigone was determined when she made up her mind to bury her brother. She was an agent of her words and took up the risks that accompanied to her deeds. Antigone was very passionate from the beginning to her death and she displayed tremendous courage when facing the death penalty. Moreover, Antigone, as a female individual, confronted bravely with the state and the authority of Creon. Throughout
Both Sophocles and Jean Anouilh use the simple story-line of a girl defying her uncle and king in the face of death to reflect upon the events and attitudes of their days. Sophocles' Antigone models the classical pattern of tragedy by incorporating key elements such as a tragic hero with a fatal flaw and the Man-God-Society triangle. Creon is the tragic hero who disturbs the natural harmony of Thebes by denying Polyneices a funeral. Antigone is the catalyst who forces him to reckon with the consequences of his pride and arrogance. In the twentieth century, Jean Anouilh takes Sophocles' drama, strips it down to its core, and weaves an entirely different version of the story. Anouilh redefines "tragedy" by removing the conventional tragic
As the play begins Antigone is just meeting up with her sister and is telling her about the decree of King Creon. Antigone and her sister, Ismene, had two brothers who had killed each other on the battlefield. One of their brothers, Eteocles, was buried with the military honors of a soldier’s funeral, and yet the other, Polyneices, was to be left out to be food for the carrion birds since he died fighting against the city of Thebes. King Creon forbade publicly for anyone to bury the body of Polyneices under the penalty of death. Antigone is now determined to bury her brother and wants Ismene to help her. Ismene does not want to go against what the king has ordered and is fearful of what may become of her if she
In 1995 the FBI counted 7,947 incidents of hate crimes, and in 2013 they counted 5,928 incidents (www.nbcnews.com). These statistics show that the issue of discrimination has gotten better, but still an issue where more action needs to be taken. In the past, we got to see the true face of racial discrimination in Harper Lee’s famous novel, To Kill A Mockingbird. In this novel we could see how everyday interactions, romance and the criminal justice system were influenced by racism, and how people made decisions based on racial prejudice. Nowadays we know that many governments and groups are trying
First off, I would rent the space to the theater company for the production of “Hair”. The reason behind renting is both parties could profit from the theater production in the chapel. When thinking logically, since the parish closed due to economic reasons they would be earning money i.e. the rent. The theater company benefits from the money earned from the turnout. It is technically a win-win for both sides. There are no longer religious activities at the chapel and the space is available for events and other uses as well. A theater production is like any other event, and is entertainment without age restrictions on attendance. Therefore, there is no reason for it to be forbade. Just because there is some minor language and adult