Critical Analysis : Moral Reasoning

According to Keller’s article, the law would protect children. It would discourage parents from using drugs which would create a better home environment. It would also ensure that state money would be used for supporting families, not recreational drugs (Keller). Rep. John McCaherty said “The bill will show the state expects TANF recipients to be responsible with public money.” (Qtd. in Keller). The idea behind those that support this legislation is that the state is responsible for ensureing that taxpayer’s money doesn’t ultimately end up buying illegal substances and drug testing is an effective means to ensure this.

According to the definition of the Moral Compass text, moral compass is the reflective, international adoption of values and behaviors as a framework for realizing the good in oneself, in others, and in the social and material environment. My own moral compass is constructed mainly by my parents and the eastern social values and principles of relationships, which are largely influenced by the thoughts and ideas of Buddhism, Taoism and the Confucianism. Among them, Confucianism affects my country’s social values and furthermore my parents and my moral compass the most. In the contrast of Western culture, Confucianism puts a huge emphasis on the relationships between individuals in family, school,

Drug problems costs the US billions of dollars every year from disease, crime, accidents, child abuse, domestic violence, homelessness, and lost wages that causes deaths and other serious economic and social consequences (Hunter). The crimes include stealing, drug trafficking, murder, robbery, domestic violence, breaking and entering, child abuse and neglect, and assault. Health care problems, such as overdoses, HIV/AIDS, hepatitis, and tuberculosis, are often results of substance abuse. Requiring drug testing of TANF recipients who are at risk for drug abuse is a step in the right direction to help addicts overcome addiction, gain employment, and become responsible citizens in society. It also helps efforts in the long term to deter drug abuse costs of healthcare, law enforcement, and prisons where addicts usually resort to crime to support their habits.

The United States has many welfare programs, such a Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) that provide social welfare payments to those in need. Often, these benefits are abused by drug users those who lack the ability or motivation to find employment and become self-sufficient. As a result, several states have attempted to implement drug testing as a requirement to receive benefits. Proponents of drug testing believe that incorporating drug testing into the welfare systems allows the government to provide those with drug addictions the needed treatment and suspend the benefits from those who continue to use drugs and test positive after treatment. They also claim that in the long

In this paper we will discuss the final stages of how a topic becomes a policy. The paper will discuss formulation, implementation, and the legislation stage. These stages must be done in this order to ensure the policy is being formed the correct way and not scattered around. This paper will also consist of the evaluation stage, analysis stage, and revision stage and describe the purpose and methodologies process for evaluating and revising a public policy.

A decision to implement mandatory drug testing may be an imperative step for preventing welfare

The United States has many welfare programs, such a Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), that provide social welfare payments to those in need. Welfare recipients statistically have a higher potential to use illicit drugs, making it more difficult to secure a job. Often, these benefits are abused by drug users those who lack the ability or motivation to find employment and become self-sufficient. Incorporating drug testing into the welfare systems allows the government to provide those with drug addictions the needed treatment and suspend the benefits from those who continue to use drug and test positive after treatment. In the long run, there will be a costs savings

Annually, the state of Texas provides welfare assistance and benefits to more than 100,000 residents – a 90 million dollar program ultimately funded by taxpayer dollars. The application of drug testing is to better enforce the appropriate utilization of welfare assistance and is not to discriminate against any one group of people “suspected” using of drugs. The application of active and systematically applying drug testing to those persons receiving welfare assistance, more accurately ensures that welfare assistance benefits are not providing money for narcotics, and to prevent cases of child neglect. Senate Bill 11 would requires each applicant and/or recipient to be drug tested upon requesting Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF). This would provide a constructive, two-way consequence in the form of: preventing taxpayer money from being used in a manner other than its’ intention in funding drug dealers, and helping current and/or

There is an ongoing argument between individuals that believe anyone on any sort of government aid should be drug tested, and many that believe it’s unconstitutional and that they should not be drug tested. One federal aid is welfare also known as (TANF). Welfare is a public assistance program that provides at least the minimum amount of economic security to people who do have a job, but don’t make enough income, and to individuals that don’t have employment. Welfare was designed to give people whose incomes are insufficient to maintain an adequate standard type of living. Many government aid gets misused and abused. In many ways drug testing welfare recipients or applicant, first and foremost would benefit the person applying for assistance,

According to Pollack et al. (2002), “Substance abuse disorders among welfare recipients have attracted special concern among policymakers and the public” (pg. 24). It is not fair that some individuals are abusing illegal substances with American tax dollars. As a result, many policymakers and the general public are angry and demand a change in the system. There needs to be major changes that would require TANF recipients to submit to random drug testing, because scheduled drug testing can always be manipulated, and the government can save on money by cutting benefits to individuals who are abusing the

So why would anyone be against drug testing welfare recipients? The tax burden to support TANF is become greater and greater. The public supports drug testing. Employers already require it for employment.

Drug testing, or DT, is considered to be any test administered to detect the presence of drugs, usually illegal substances, from a blood or urine sample. Major applications include the use to detect performance enhancing drugs in competitive athletes, employment screening used to filter candidates for hiring, and is often used by police to detect alcohol levels in drivers suspected of drunk driving. Historically, it has been applied to incriminate those suspected of consumption of illicit narcotic substances and also to confirm suspicions of illegal drug use, while individuals in sporting events undergo mandatory testing is implemented to catch those looking for a chemical upper hand to win in their sport or discipline. Yet the use of DT in the schools is becoming a far more common practice. Instead of using it to prove one’s guilt, they are being adopted as a deterrent for recreational drug usage in American youths by instilling fear that a positive test would force students to be excluded from participating in extracurricular activities that they so cherish. In the early 2000’s during a State of Union Address, President Bush stated that student DT is a proven and effective way to prevent substance abuse in adolescent students and it “is not to punish children, but to send them this message: we love you, and we don’t want to lose you” (Stuart 1057). In support of President Bush, the federal government spent over 18 million dollars on

Many high schools across the country have brought much attention to the idea of giving random drug tests to students in high school. The newfound interest in student drug testing may be as a result of recent polls, which have shown an increase in drug use among high school students. Many teachers, parents, and members of school comities are for the drug testing, while most students and some parents feel that this would be a violation of students rights as Americans, which is true.

What is the aim of moral (ethical) theory that you learned from the reading? Elaborate on this by explaining how you think that having a clearer understanding of ethics can affect your life.

Every rational being have duties, and some of the duty are universal laws. Kant believes that duty is determine though reasons. Nevertheless, I believe that duty is ambiguous for different people have various background and religion affect the way of viewing the duty they should take even though we all own the same senses.