Dbq Christian And Muslim Responses

merchants and trade from the religions origins’ origins until about 1500. Are there indications of

The infamous plague, known as the Black Death, was a deadly disease which managed to spread throughout Europe and the Middle East in the 14th century. Although both the Europeans and the Empires of Islam experienced the Black Death, each region had different responses and reasons for the causes of the disease. Empires of Islam viewed the plague as a blessing from God while Europeans believed it was a punishment from Him. As a result of the Black Death, Europeans rebelled whereas Empires of Islam respected authority. Europeans used other religions as an explanation for the start of the Black Death while Islamic empires did not blame other religions, but rather had other explanations that caused the disease.

During the time when the Black Plague struck there were two main religions in the world, Christianity and Islam. Christianity follows the teachings of Jesus Christ, God’s son. The book of the Christian is the Bible. The religion of Islam deals with submission to God, and following the teachings of Mohammed, which are spelled out in the Koran (The DBQ Project, Background Essay). An interesting topic that one might discover of this time is, how did these two religions react to the plague. Could it be possible that they acted as everyone else did at that time, or did they hold strong to their beliefs? When they Black Plague struck, the Christians and the Muslims had similar ways of dealing and responding to it.

Christian and Muslim responses to the Black Death. Indeed the Christian and Muslims specifically believed it was a punishment from God. For instance the muslims on the other hand thought if it was from God it has to be good. The christian people believed that God was punishing them for sinning. The plague killed 25 - 45% of the populations it came in contact with. They both had some similarities in trying to prevent the Christians and Muslims from getting the Black Death.

The Black Death was a catastrophic event, it caused many innocent people to lose their lives. The people had different responses to the Plague. In this specific DBQ the topic will be “How Different Were Christian and Muslim Responses” (The Black Death: How Different Were Christian and Muslim Responses, 2010). The Christian and Muslims had somewhat different and the same responses. They would either turn to religion or they divert their own path away from religion. Both Christians and Muslims had different theories on why the Black Death came to be. Either it had something to do with their religion or it was a punishment for their sins or they would blame people such as the Jews.

What was the Black Death, and how did Christianity and Muslim react to it? Well, you might not know what the Black Death is, so here is some information to start with. The Black Death began to spread in 1348, and slowly ended in 1351. Europe, Asia, Middle East, Australia, and even Hawaii suffered! Back then, Christians thought that the Black Death was just a reward from God of the people’s sins, and thought they could stop the disease by praying.

When thinking about the history of the world, one must always consider that merchants as well as trade have played an immerse role in shaping the world as it is today. They are responsible for many of the cross-cultural interactions that we have had in the past. Christianity and Islam, the two predominant religions of the world today, have both grown and spread through merchants and trade also. These two chief religions both have attitudes towards merchants and trade that have either developed or decreased overtime. According to these documents, from up to the year 1500, Christianity went from a negative view of merchants and trade to a positive view while Islam went from a positive view to a negative view, but both sides

Documents 4, 5, 7, and 8 all talk about the believed cause of the plague. Documents 7 and 8 are what the Christians believed to be true about the plague, while Document 4 talks about what the Muslims thought was the cause of the plague. Christians believed that the Jews were the cause of the plague. In response, the Christians started the “Burning of the Jews” (Doc 7). Although most Christians believed that the Jews were causing the plague, some Christians such as Pope Clement VI thought “… (the charge) that Jews have provided the cause of the occasion for such a crime is without plausibility.” (Doc 8) Muslims did not think that any one particular group was at fault for the plague, as shown in the quote “…plague is a blessing from God; at the least, a Muslim should devoutly accept the divine act,” by Muhammad al-Manbiji and the quote “We know that whatever we suffer is just the reward of our sins,” by Gabriele de Mussis. (Doc 4) Some non-religious explanations of the plague include miasma, excessive clothing, and the conjunction of Saturn, Jupiter, and Mars.

In Medieval Europe, many people thought “bad air” was the cause of the Black Plague (Document K). Back in the Middle Ages, the Black Plague was a very severe disease that went around Europe and Asia. It killed about 1/3 of the population and lasted 3 years (Background Information). The disease was carried by rats. It had gotten to the humans by fleas, which had gotten the plague by the rats (The True Cause of the Plague). The effects of the black plague in Medieval Europe were a decrease in the population and economy, new jobs for the serfs, and religion.

Many lives were lost during the outbreak of the Bubonic Plague or the Black Death in the fourteenth century. During this time religion was a critical need in the lives of humans and many people in a certain religion reacted differently. A perfect example of this would be the Christian and the Islams. According to the 2010 DBQ Document of World History, one can conclude that the responses of the Christian and Islam were not very similar. They are different because each religion believed that the disease came from different origin, each one sought different practices of preventing the disease, and the living of each religion responded differently to the plague, and their actions during the outbreak.

The Black Death was a plague carried by fleas on rats and it was very deadly. It started in the mid-14th century. The Black Death did not discriminate, anyone could get it. Religion was at its all time high during the time the Plague arrived in Europe. Two major religions that got the Black Death were Christians and Muslims. Muslims got the Plague in 1333 and Christians got the Plague in 1348 but their responses to the Black Death were greatly different but sometimes they were the same.

From the depths of the Middle East during the Post-Classical period, two of the most powerful world religions emerged. Islam and Christianity, although sharing many similarities, also had their fair share of disagreements, one being their responses to the Black Death. The religion, demography, and interactions all contributed to the differentiation of Muslim and Christian reactions. Christians thought that the Black Death was sent from God as a punishment and blamed the Jews, while Muslims considered it a blessing and did not accuse any minority of initiating the outbreak.

From 1347 to 1362, The Black Death was a plague that affected over half of Europe, leading many people to death and famine. Medicine back in the 13th century wasn’t as technologically advanced as it is today in the 21st century. So, nobody knew the cause of the illness and how it was spreading. Therefor, everyone was in fear of when they too would be struck by the sickness and die. This was because of the common belief that God was condemning mankind for their sins. The disease consisted of flu like symptoms and inflamed lymph nodes. Although the people believed they were being punished, in reality the Mongolian Empire at the time is the source to blame for this illness. The Mongol Empire was at the time very large, and needing to expand its

In the middle ages people had no idea about how any disease such as the Black Death could spread. The Europeans think “it disseminated by the influence of the celestial bodies, or sent upon them by God in his just wrath” (Boccaccio). In other words, they think the plague came from the sky or sent by God. They think maybe it is God’s way of cleansing the earth or punishing them for their unfair behaviors. Some think that a supernatural origin caused the disease. This disease is a bacterium infection which has a variety of symptoms, such as, nose bleeding, tumors in the groin or armpits and black spots or

They believed that the Black Death was a punishment from God for sins against god such as greed, blasphemy, heresy, and fornication. The logic to overcome the plague in the Middle Ages was to gain God’s forgiveness. People took this thought in many different ways. Some people believed they had to purge their communities of criminals. In result of that reaction, thousands of Jews were killed in 1348 and 1349. Some lashed out on neighbors, others worried about themselves. Upper-class men joined flagellants that traveled from town to town and publicly displayed penance and punishment by beating each other with sharp pieces of metal. Flagellants repeated this ritual for thirty three and a half days, then moved to the next town. The flagellants brought some comfort to people who felt powerless, but it worried the Pope that it would disrupt people. By cause of the Pope’s worrying, the Pope disbanded the flagellants ("Black Death"). The Black Death had a massive effect on the way people lived their daily lives. Doctors refused to see patients, shopkeepers closed stores, priests refused to administer last rites. It also affected cows, sheep, goats, pigs, and chicken ("Black Death"). People's businesses suffered because people were locked away in their homes. One in three people died in infected homes, in some cases whole families died (“London Plagues”). Husbands abandoned their wives, parents abandoned their kids, priests and doctors refused to see patients to save themselves (Butler). Some threw sick servants onto the streets, others refused to help sick family and friends (“London