preview

Death And Justice Koch Analysis

Decent Essays

Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is nothing new. It has been around for thousands of years. It is mentioned in the bible as punishment for over 30 different crimes. It is also found in the Code of Hammurabi, which dates back to 1750 BC. England, America’s “mother nation,” had seven crimes that were considered capital offenses by the end of the 15th century, and by the year 1800 there were over 200 capital crimes listed for the country (“Capital”). In the U.S. today the death penalty is a topic of concern for many. Former New York City mayor, Edward I. Koch, in his article, “Death and Justice” describes the situation perfectly. After using an analogy between capital punishment and cancer, and the “barbaric” methods we use to treat cancer, he wrote, “Murder is not the “disease” we are trying to cure. The disease is …show more content…

Murderers who fall under this category are essentially given “licenses to kill.” How dangerous is that? These people can do just about whatever they please, and have done so in the past. In an Edward I. Koch article “Death and Justice” we see an example of this. Koch describes the story of Lemuel Smith, who was serving four life sentences for murder, and another two life sentences for kidnapping and robbery in New York’s Green Haven Prison. Smith coerced a female corrections officer into an office room and strangled her. He then proceeded to mangle and dismember her body. Another life sentence for Smith at this point means nothing at all, and because New York doesn’t practice the death penalty, Smith has indeed been given a “license to kill” (Koch 2). This is not something that we can tolerate; prisoners such as these are not really prisoners, they are made free because the death penalty is not applicable to

Get Access