preview

Definition Essay - Defining Professionalism

Decent Essays

Defining Professionalism

Academics believe that professional occupations are those that are full-time occupations, have a commitment to a calling, have formalized organization, are based on specialized education of exceptional duration and difficulty, exhibit a service orientation, and are autonomous. Students feel that a professional is anyone who acts in a professional way and has creditable knowledge of their field. The two are vying for increased recognition in the elite group known as professionals. The academic community wishes to restrict the values of professionalism’s definition. Society wishes to let itself into the professional community by broadening those values. Each side seeks its own best interests in …show more content…

Can a corporate CEO not be a professional? Can the honor also be denied to a computer programmer making $100,000 salary?

The surveyed students of Clarkson University disagree with Moore. Their ideas of professionalism were much more lenient, and included CEOs, programmers, and nearly all other skilled jobs. A professional, by their definition, “has to go through intense training and must receive a degree [that] requires hard work and study” and “devotes [their] whole life.” The students commonly listed doctors, lawyers, scientists, and reporters, which may fit Moore’s ideals, but they also listed business people, engineers, bankers, and trades such as mechanics and construction workers. These occupations may not fit Moore’s criteria. To the students, a professional is anyone who acts in a professional way and has creditable knowledge of their field.

The reason for the disagreement is a conflict in interests between the two communities. The academic community is firmly seated in the professional world. They do not have to contend with being a member of professionalism’s gray area. It is in the best interest of the academics to limit the definition of professionalism, thus making it more of an elite group. However, the students have adopted the beliefs of their parents, who wish to broaden professionalism, to include themselves in the elite group. This is not to say that the students wish to include all occupations as

Get Access