Both Jefferson and Hamilton had a positive vision of what American culture ought to turn into. Does the present United States take after a greater amount of Hamilton's or Jefferson's thoughts?
Alexander Hamilton followed the constitutional theory of loose construction or also known as implied powers (Module 7, Lecture I Hamilton v. Jefferson, Slide 9). He believed that if the constitution didn’t prohibit a certain thing, then the government is able to do it (Module 7, Lecture I Hamilton v. Jefferson, Slide 9). While as for Thomas Jefferson, he followed the theory of strict construction or known as expressed powers (Module 7, Lecture I Hamilton v. Jefferson, Slide 9). Jefferson wanted to restrict the national government to exactly what was
Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson represent the polarizing ends of the political spectrum in the early days of the United States government. Traditionally, Hamilton has been viewed as being in favor of a strong central government and a loose interpretation and application of the United States Constitution while Jefferson favored a weak central government and a strict interpretation of the Constitution (Foner, 2008).
Although Thomas Jefferson and Hamilton’s were beliefs about how the government should function led to the creation of the political parties, Alexander Hamilton’s of a strong federal government, implementation
In the history of America, Thomas Jefferson, the Secretary of State, and Hamilton, the Secretary of the Treasury, were two of the greatest leaders of our country. Although they both lead the country, that's where the similarities end as they had opposing views on everything. Jefferson was a republican while Hamilton was a federalist. Jefferson had been opposed to all of Hamilton's ideas, such as his financial plan, his interpretation of the powers of the government, his foreign policy, and his vision for the future of America. Jefferson was against Hamilton's views because his financial plan would ultimately destroy democracy in America, his interpretation of the powers of
Hamilton wanted to build the economic structure similar to Great Britain. Jefferson's economic structure was a more independent economic structure that he argued was best against Hamilton. Jefferson and Hamilton both had foreign policy’s with other countries. The French war played a big part in their foreign policy. Their views of the French war made the men become even stronger
Throughout the period of 1790 to 1825, Thomas Jefferson and his party of Republicans often had differing ideals than Alexander Hamilton and the Federalists. During this time, Federalists had a desire for a strong central government and trade rights. Jefferson and his Republicans, on the other hand, were strong advocates for state power against the tyrannical central government. As a prominent politician, Jefferson spoke out against Hamilton ideas such as a national bank; when Jefferson became president, however, some of his views change and seem to reflect those of Hamilton.
Hamilton expressed dissatisfaction with both of the plans brought forward to the convention. The Virginia plan, which was a proposal to completely abandon the Articles of Confederation, and replace it with a bicameral national legislature, an executive branch selected by the legislature, a judiciary, and a council of revision with the power veto, and the New Jersey plan, which suggested to keep the Articles of Confederation, but revise it to give Congress the power to tax, regulate commerce, and choose plural executive and members of a supreme court. Hamilton felt both these plans lacked a strong central government. He was specifically displeased with the New Jersey plan “being fully convinced” Madison writes “that no amendment of the Confederation, leaving the States in possession of their Sovereignty could possibly answer the purpose.” pg 18-19. He feared that either of these plans would leave the newly founded country weakened and “…would ultimately destroy the confederation…” pg 20. Finally, though Hamilton would given the federal government more power, he supported what was to be and is now the Constitution of the United States of America and he became one of its leading supporters during the ratification process. Though Jefferson was unable to join the convention due to his duties in France as
First off, Jefferson was challenged with many circumstances during his presidency that required him to go against his strict constructionist beliefs. Some of these included the Louisiana Purchase and the british impressment of US
The clash between Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton’s political views was one of great historical interest. Some say that the differences between these two started the first political parties in America. Jefferson believed in a strict and explicit construction of the constitution, favored an agricultural based economy, sympathized and encouraged the French Revolution, and believed the common people could be trusted to have a role in the country’s governing. Hamilton, on the other hand, believed the opposite about all of those topics. The dissention between these two members of the cabinet worried President Washington, who ultimately sided with Hamilton on most issues.
Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton impacted United States history during the 1700s by helping in many ways to mold America. However, they both had very different views on government issues that concerned the American people. Thomas Jefferson was a anti-federalist while Hamilton was a federalist. They both differ from the forms of government they support. !! Hamilton believed in the central government being strong and did not have a particular interpretation of the Constitutional views.
Jefferson had deep faith in the common people. Jefferson had a good point of view on many things that were better than Hamilton. Jefferson and Hamilton had two very different opinions on government. In my own opinion i feel that jefferson had the better points of view in most things that had to do with government. These things ( most importantly ) being economics, the structure of government, and who should govern.
Hamilton and Jefferson had very different opinions. This undoubtedly caused them to debate heavily during the times they served this position in the government. However, it also gave Washington a wide range of ideas coming from his closest advisors.
Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton were very different in their methods to try and develop America as a nation. The two were very much alike because they both were avid Americans, and wanted to see the nation succeed. Both men were very involved in the U.S. Government and tried to voice their opinions on
Conflicting views and contrasting ideologies have always existed throughout the history of United States politics. Alexander Hamilton, who led Federalist Party, believed that a powerful central government was necessary while Thomas Jefferson, who led the Jeffersonian Republican Party, favored an agrarian nation with most of the power left to the states. Although Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson were similar in that they both harbored good intentions and tried to keep the best interests in mind for the future of the United States, their policies were drastically different. Without doubt, both of their contrasting ideas served a vital role in forming the government.
Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton were completely at odds in their vision on how America was to develop. Hamilton wanted to concentrate power in a centralized federal government with limited access and Jefferson wished to diffuse it among all the eligible freemen of the time. Alexander Hamilton feared anarchy and distrusted popular rule while Jefferson feared tyranny and thought in terms of liberty and freedom.
Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson were key Founding Fathers of America who contributed to its freedom and independence. Both men were influential leaders of their time whose visions for the future of the country were clearly contrasting. Hamilton believed for a strong federal government and an economy based on banking. While Jefferson desired for a nation to be controlled by the states and its people. Their competing visions for the United States are still in debate until this day. Although Jefferson’s ideas were significant to America, many of Hamilton’s philosophy still holds in today’s government.