preview

Different Political Sysytems

Better Essays

In the vast majority of political systems, which have gone through the processes of federalisation or decentralization, the courts have assumed a prominent role in resolving intergovernmental disputes. However, academics, such as Alan Trench and Robert Hazel, agree, that courts’ role in the working of devolution in the United Kingdom was limited. They name political congruence in the UK as a main factor minimizing the role of the judiciary in the devolution process. There also is a number of secondary factors adding to it. Such as the limited role accorded to lawyers and legal issues in the UK’s governmental system, the high degree of flexibility of the devolution settlements and a political nature of the UK’s constitution, which favours resolution of intergovernmental disputes by means other than courts. Despite the chance that once devolution legislation comes into force, the case law builds up and devolved legislatures become more active, courts’ role is more likely to become more significant as a result of third-party litigation, Alan Trench predicts that the role of courts in most intergovernmental matters is unlikely to change due to hindering factors mentioned above. We will elaborate on them further.
It was predicted before devolution process was started in 1999 that the courts will be called upon to resolve numerous arising intergovernmental disputes on new constitutional agreements, as it happened in … Which will increase their role as policy-makers and, as a

Get Access