preview

Director Stanley Nelson 's The Black Panthers : Vanguard Of The Revolution

Good Essays

Director Stanley Nelson’s The Black Panthers: Vanguard of the Revolution attempts to document the history of the notorious Black Panthers from the mid 1960s to about the mid 1970s. The documentary admirably tries to showcase the pros and cons of the bigger than life movement. I think Nelson is largely able to accomplish this with his use of first hand footage. The way the footage was woven into the narrative made statistics and facts more real for me, because I see the children being feed, the illustrations of Emory Douglas, or where Fred Hampton was slain. A key factor that I would place in the same category of the footage is the score of the documentary. In all honestly, my attention was not peaked until I saw the Chi-Lites. The music …show more content…

Despite my overall positive opinion of the documentary, I did have some problems with the documentary. I feel that the documentary does not effectively focus in on the ideologies that defined the movement. They are mentioned occasionally but I felt like they should have been woven more thoroughly into the narrative like gray area between Black Power, socialism, and Marxism theories. Also, there seem to be a large focus on that type of sensationalized media that we are always warned about in this course. The division between Newton and Cleaver sections was portrayed in my opinion as a superficial squabble not a true conflict of ideology and the direction of the movement. Instead of just focusing on their public quarrels like the phone calls maybe they could have interviewed more people that chose a side and their reasonings behind doing that. In addition to interviewing those people, I think the documentary would have benefitted from interviews by more women. The documentary states that women were a large portion of the “rank and file” but if I am recalling correctly less than seven were interviewed in comparison to far more men. Nelson made it seem like the themes of gender and sexuality in the movement would be explored but it barely skated the surface like where was the discussion of womanism in the movement. I think that is a big problem that

Get Access