preview

Disagreement Will Be Protected By Law As Well As Organization

Better Essays

Disagreement will appear in every organization. How a person handled the disagreement will make a difference in the organization. However, employees should be protected by law as well as organization. This assignment presents several situations where liability issues can occur at any given time. Also, this assignment identifies how the following case applies to the three scenarios: Abella v. Simon, 831 F. Supp.2d 1316 (2011) U.S. Dist. LEXIS 136238 (S.D. Fla. 2011), and how to evade liability issue. Scenario 1 (Filing a Police Report): Ms. Tree a local of Lee, Florida filed a complaint. Ms. Tree has been arrested for many criminal acts. Ms. Tree complained that after being released on December 3, 2012, somebody broke into the …show more content…

The Merry Court says that if a false report is used in some way which damages a subject, some form of legal right might be available, but that is not the situation in the present case. The Constitution is not violated by a police officer 's failure to make a report, the creation of an inaccurate report, or the failure to have an inaccurate report corrected. “This claim fails because there is no rights to have the police write a police report. Courts have held that there is no legitimate right to correct police information. An allegedly incorrect police report fails to implicate constitutional rights; Landrigan v. City of Warwick, 628 F.2d 736, 745 (1st Cir.1980). If it is not a constitutional violation to file a false police report, it cannot be a constitutional” (as cited in Abella v. Simon, 831 F.Supp.2d 1316, (S.D.Fla.2011). Both subjects claiming the officer not filing a police report correctly or not writing a report. Courts have held that there is no constitutional right to a correct police report. Police officer declined to write a police report (as mentioned in Abella v. Simon, 831 F.Supp.2d 1316 (S.D.Fla.2011). Scenario 2 (Recording incidents of violating of rights): Mr. Heir was walking on side of the road with his fishing rods in Deer County. While fishing, Mr. Heir was openly carrying a firearm in a shoulder holster. Of course, the County police stopped Mr. Heirs to determine if he were a

Get Access