Does procreation lead to a successful city-state? Socrates believed that to be true. The Sexual Congress has no elitist mentality about what would occur from their procreation. They both had different ideas about how the sexual intercourse would occur. Socrates had the idea that only the guardians must be able to have sex, and the inferior people may have children, but they must be hidden. Especially in the case of a deformed offspring. In The Sexual Congress, men must first have sex with the ugliest ‘broad’ in order to be able to have sex with a beautiful, young, soft, and smooth girl. I believe that these two ideas collide. Socrates talks about how each gender may have their differences, but they are the same in nature. While The Sexual Congress does not touch on each gender and their differences. Also, Socrates talks about each gender and their functions in society. While Praxagora’s law is only about sex and in which order it must occur in. The only big similarity with these laws is, about whom they can have sex with, and when they can have sex. Socrates believed that in a perfect city the guardians must procreate in order to have the best possible offspring. But, the sexual intercourse must take part at a certain time of year, and the guardians may only have sexual intercourse during that set time period. These guardians must also be in their prime. Women guardians from the age of twenty to the age of forty, and men the age of 20 until they are fifty five. If the
Socrates explains his theory of the city and its rules as the nature of ones life. It is not moral to fight against it. We were welcomed to live in it and accept it how it is.
The citizens are not only told that God created them in the Earth, but he made them all different. Each class is made of a different metal. The rulers were gold, for they have the greatest honor. The auxiliaries were silver, and the craftsmen were brass and iron. After they have been created, they lead normal human lives and they are able to have children. Unfortunately, sometimes parents from one line will have children from another. God states above all else, the races should be kept separate and pure. So if a gold parent for example, has a silver or iron son, this son would have to leave the gold world that his parents come from and take his place in the silver or iron world being an auxiliary or craftsman. The situation could work in reverse also. A silver parent could give birth to a gold son. In this case, the son would leave the parent and take his place in higher rank. Socrates says it is best to tell the people that the races must be kept pure because the prophets have spoken, and the city will be destroyed if the rule is not observed and followed.
In book IV Adeimantus wonders that except guardians who have the most power everyone seems happy in the city. According to Socrates in the city there is not such a duty to make rulers or guardians happy in fact their job is to provide justice and make citizen happy and do any necessary thing in order to live in honour and justice.
Many of Socrates’ statements suggest that the moral education offered to each class is substantially different. For example, Socrates asks Glaucon, ‘In the city we’re establishing, who do you think will prove to be better men, the guardians, who receive the education we’ve described, or the cobblers, who are educated in cobblery?’ (456d). Socrates suggests that his city will be harmonized through persuasion (431e-432a) and he claims that the city will run smoothly with relatively few laws (427a). No one will ever find the need to think, speak, or behave in an unacceptable manner because they will not have the mental capability of even thinking to do such a
On the subject of the Guardians, education is one of high importance. The Guardians are meant to be brought up in such a way that the City can depend on them to not only being highly intelligent but also fierce fighters. Plato breaks down their education into two categories : gymnastics and music. These two categories serve to enhance both the body and mind to the highest level. However, it is important to note that Plato planned to filter and censor the majority of what was given to the Guardians in the mind category. This filter included removing any and all teachings of Greek mythology, as well as only allowing the Guardians to study what was deemed beautiful and just by Plato and his attendants. The claim made to support this was “ we can
In The Republic, Socrates idealized the perfect city. One of the aspects that he deliberated on was the raising of children and family structure. The conclusion reached by Socrates is that no parent will know his own offspring or any child his parents (457 d). It was Socrate's belief that the best atmosphere would be created in a communal upbringing of the city's children. In the same sense, he believed that they should take every precaution to insure that no mother knows her own child (460 c). Not even the mother, the traditional child-rearer, would be permitted to know or have a say in the lives of her own children, but
Book V of The Republic finds Socrates explaining the practical details necessary in the creation of an ideal polis. He proposes a system for population control and human eugenics based on a lottery of sorts which will determine who will mate with whom and when. The lottery is “rigged” by the rulers in order that the best of the “herd” will mate much more frequently than others. However, only the rulers of this society will know the lottery is rigged. This system will presumably assure that children will be conceived as the result of reason, not irrational behaviors such as love or lust, and will
As Socrates was building the city, according to his different accounts of how city ought to be. There were different classes of people and the position they held in the cities community. In a just city as Socrates claims there will be citizens, guardians and a philosopher king as the ruler of the city. In order to maintain order, politics influence on human nature by politically influencing laws such as stopping peoples from changing their division of labour. For example, Socrates claims that it is impossible for an individual to practice many crafts proficiently as discussed by the companions earlier. (Plato, 1992, p. 49). The reason there is division of peoples in the city is so the city can run efficiently, if there were many people doing many thing, there will not be an efficiency of work. For this reason, politics constrained human nature in which individual as human nature wants to do more than one thing, but it is stopped through influence of ideology of how one ought to be. That individual does not want to do one job for the rest of his life; this form of ideology is first form pre capital which was discussed in the republic. Continuing, as politics influence increases in the republic the more constrained human nature becomes. In politics, the political thought of Socrates creates a guardian for city, a protector to defend against an enemy or to conquer land for the city. In
In ancient Greece, there was one dominant city-state, or Polis as the ancient Greeks called it, and this was Athens. It was a beautiful society that enjoyed art and literature very much and valued things like wholeness and excellence. However, one thing the Athenians did not value was women. They were deemed inferior by men, and treated more as a decoration rather than a human being.
In The Republic Book IV, pp. 130e-136d, Socrates sets out to prove that societal justice is analogous to individual justice. In order to substantiate the analogy, Socrates compares the individual and the city. As he previously defined, justice in the city involves the power relationships between the different parts of the city, namely the guardians, the auxiliaries, and the producers.
To be begin with, an individual cannot be good until they have attained the virtue of wisdom, and the same can be said for the city. For the individual, the person must not only be wise himself, but his soul must have wisdom. The only way to achieve this according to Socrates, is through for philosophy. In this way it is the same for the city, for in the city, wisdom lies with the guardians as they are the philosophers. The guardians are put in charge of the city because of their knowledge of how the city should be run. Because of this, the Guardians wisdom becomes the City’s. (Book IV)
Why moderation is considered an importance in the soul and utopia city? Socrates says in the Republic of Plato that there are four basic virtues that are required for a noble life in the just city. These four basic virtues are: wisdom, courage, moderation, and just.1 Specifically, in book IV of the Republic of Plato, three of the four virtues are discussed by Socrates. Out of the three, moderation is the up most important.
In book VI of The Republic, Plato uses Socrates as his mouthpiece to reveal the ideal city. Plato points out that the idea city is based on the foundations of three basic forms. Consequently, these three forms are manifested in the individuals that make up the city. The functioning of the city will thus depend on the analogy of the structures within the city and within the souls of the people. The main purpose of this paper is to analyze the argument by Socrates with respect to the three forms in the city and in the soul. Additionally, the paper seeks to analyze the rationale behind Socrates’ comparison and subsequent establishment of analogy between the forms in the city and the forms in the city in the context of justice. The paper also
Socreates talked about the importance of education in both book 3 and 4. What I found interesting was his point of gaining music and physical education separately, that the knowledge from physical exercise would only work for body and have no improvement for one’s soul. On page 107 he also emphasized that the “education and upbringing” was crucial for individual to learn and obey the laws. I feel like all the points he mentioned, including the key factors (knowledge, courage, temperance and justice) for a good city are served for the city itself as a whole regardless of individuals. Things are organized and planned. For the only a small number of those who own the knowledge of guardianship, would be the leaders of the city. Individuals should
He clearly realizes that men and women are different, but he is seeking to figure out whether these differences affect their abilities, ultimately determining whether it would affect their roles and their effectiveness in Socrates’ Republic. Socrates figures that the main difference between the two is their genitalia, but he believes that that has barely impact on their abilities. Additionally, regarding activities, Socrates finds that there is generally an equal distribution of talent between the two genders. Thus, he concludes that there are not any major significant differences between the two, so they are in fact both able to assume the role of