Dumbing us Down Through Public Education
Many of us believe that public education has been with us for quite some time. This stands to reason as we know that our parents, our grandparents, even our great grandparents, have participated in public education of some type, but it is at this point where things begin to get fuzzy. The truth is that public education as we know it today, free public education, available to anyone, regardless of class, social standing, race or religion, is an American phenomenon and has only been in existence, in the form that we now understand it, since the early 20th century,(Plant, Decline 213). Truth be told, at the onset, government sanctioned education was most often met with resistance, even violence,
…show more content…
She states that, on nearly all accounts, her efforts were met with similar back-lash from school administrators, government officials and educational organizations, such as the State Literary Resource Center of Maine, the National Education Association and various teachers unions (Iserbyt Deliberate 3-5, 16-24). At one point she implemented a penmanship program in her class, teaching her students to make certain shapes, those which are used in the writing of letters and numbers in a repetitious manner, to the rhythm of specially composed music. Iserbyt states that such has proven to create connections in the brain that prove to be useful in other areas later in life. She states that this is where she met with her strongest reprimands, all while she assumed, and rightfully so, that she was doing what was best for her students (Iserbyt Sovereign, pt 3, 0:33, Deliberate, 142). In spite of her intermittent run-ins with higher-ups, Iserbyt did manage to promote and advance in her career as an educator. It was here where her belief that a conspiracy was afoot and, in her mind, confirmed her understanding of the true agenda in American education. Iserbyt says that she observed many disturbing trends in her tenure as a school board administrator, certainly not the least of which was the continual and gradual reduction in the instruction of basic skills. Especially in the area of mathematics and reading, Iserbyt states
Public education in America began in the early to mid-19th century with the simple goal of “uniting the American population by instilling common moral and political values” (Spring, 2012, p. 5). Our country was founded by men who designed the constitution so that it could be amended to accommodate changing political and social climates. They believed in the ideology of the American dream which “holds out a vision of both individual success and the collective good of all” (Hochschild & Scovronick, 2004, p. 1). It is with this same ideology that our public schools were
To begin, the public education system is unfair to the children. Students are treated the same, regardless of their intellect. In a world where everyone is not equally intelligent, yet everyone is to be taught at an equal standard, the brightest, who have the most potential to improve society, don't achieve the education they deserve, while the slowest remain frustrated. It is also unfair to the community who must pay the annual taxes whether they have children going to school or not. Government run education systems remove the core foundation from education that this country was brought up with--competition. Without competition, government run schools don't compete and therefore do not improve. Market competition has a way of constantly fighting to provide the best service possible, constantly improving and changing, while weeding out the worst. Lastly, public education is
Public Education reform has emotional, political, and economic ties due to the impact America endures from the public school system. New American Academy writer Yehudi Meshchaninov writes,
Andrew R. Deras Dr. Jide Osikomaiya English 100 8 September 2016 The Most Compelling Problems In American Schools As we delve back into a new year for students and teachers alike returning to school to continue with the daily life of academics and learning, we all must be understanding of what exactly we are sending our peers and children back to. It should be no surprise to most of us that throughout the years we have seen countless upon countless examples from the news and through others, that our school system is flawed in some way, shape or form. It is no longer a coincidence that our students are only achieving 36th from the top in all total curriculum (Arnett). This is also evident to anyone who may happen to own a T.V. and has been a viewer to these numerous articles describing these horrible issues we have within schools firsthand (ABC News). Not only that, but schooling can also be further compromised by politics and law related issues (Ravitch). What my goal for the essay I am submitting to you is; to give my opinions on the current situation of public schooling in America, discuss the issues, and back my points I will be presenting, with concrete evidence I have uncovered in my research. I would like to make it clear that my stance on the current situation is that there is not only a singular problem with public education, but a number of issues that inhibit students to learn properly and function as productive members of society. An excellent place to start would
The human mind is perhaps the greatest object on the earth, animate or inanimate, but without the proper training, the mind is a relatively useless tool. Through the development of formal education systems, humans as a whole have tried to ensure the training of all minds so as to continue prosperity for the world. Most of the time, though, education systems do not realize the harm they are doing to developing minds and the subsequent negative consequences. Among the largest of these inadequate education systems is the American primary schooling system. The American education system is in fact failing; it continues to deplete children of their natural creativity and thirst for knowledge while preaching conformity, which in turn creates an
While reading the piece, “Straight from the source: What works for fist-generation college students” I was somewhat conflicted. I applaud the state of Texas for taking steps in order to increase enrollment of first-generation students in higher education institutions, However, I feel like these steps aren’t addressing the bigger issue; that being the broken education system in America. Until this bigger issue is addressed and the problem is dealt with from the root, anything that is done will only be addressing the symptoms caused by the real problem which is America’s broken education system.
Since 1983 public education has been an issue in America. The system has been constantly changing every year with reforms. This constant change has been driven by the American people’s perception that education has declined and something should be done about it. First there was an increased emphasis on basic skills, making school years longer and more graduation requirements. Second, many began focusing on increasing teachers professionalism. Third, they began restructuring many things such as how the schools were organized and how the school day was structured etc. Now today the most of the American people believe that not enough money is given to public schooling. They associate academic improvement with the money the school is funded.
As Michael A. Resnick, associate executive director for advocacy and issues management at the National School Boards Association, writes, “Public education means a tuition-free, publicly funded system that must provide an education to each child in a neighborhood school within a publicly governed school system.” If tuition is defined as the cost to attend, then this statement is technically true. However, if tuition is thought of as fees in general, then today’s public schooling system is contradicting itself. Although public education was originally defined as a free system, being a student at a public school is accompanied by a host of costs nowadays, which for some students, can limit the experience.
When reflecting upon my understanding of free and appropriate public education, I think about when I was younger. I was given the opportunity to get a public-school education from Preschool up until grade 12, one of which my father always told me to cherish because when he was younger he
The public-school system in place in the United States could possibly one of the most important welfare state programs that exists in the country. My entire education until college was provided through the public-school system, which I believe had one of the strongest influences on the person I have become. Attending school with no cost did not always appear to be an opportunity I should be grateful for, but in reflection I understand how important it was. While the academic and common knowledge provided by the education system was critical in increasing my life chance, and getting me into a school like Carleton, there are other aptitudes it presented that were just as important.
This rhetoric, which suggests that public education is failing, is not only misleading, it is dangerous because it may erode public confidence in the very institutions on which our capacity for a democratic response depends.Criticism of public education has continued unabated since the publication of A Nation At Risk in 1983. Stimulated in large part by new international economic realities, by a domestic economy based on traditional production models, and by changing domestic demographics, the critics have sought solutions to these challenging problems by turning to schools and educators. The data cited by critics of public schools were accepted at face value until the late 1980's. However, since
The fact that the only problem you see with public education is the “curriculum” leads me to believe that you really do not know the real problems facing public education. You say the new curriculum is all about the “almighty dollar” when even prior to common core it still was about the almighty dollar. I know of kids, me being one of them, who were put in certain classes that they were not supposed to be in so the school can meet their quotas. Moreover, the fact that a teacher who does not do their job correctly, or to use a personal example, sits in the back of the room on a lawn chair while their students watch weekly movies, is a problem. Also, it is a problem when a teacher who works hard does not get a better raise then the chump I just
The United States prides itself on its public education system making it a core value of many families. The level of education a person has will influence their career achievements. Americans expect their public system of education to provide a solid curriculum. Most of the people in the United States place their trust in the public school system in which they support through taxes. This trust although is contradicted by the public system of education’s current shape. Much of the schools in the United States are either deteriorating, or failing all together. The drawbacks of public education create an unhealthy environment for student learning.
Nowadays, there is universal access to free public schools across the United States for kindergarten through 12th grade. So how did this happen? In 1877, Rutherford B. Hayes became the first president who started thinking about making American education available to everyone. It has taken a lot of public effort to make widespread access to free public schools by the progressive movement in the beginning of 1890’s. Around 1940, half of all young people were able to graduate from high school and in 2013 it reached 81 percent. But it’s not enough for our world education right now. A college degree is the new high school diploma.
“Youth who drop out [of high school] generally experience negative outcomes—unemployment, underemployment, and incarceration.” The inadequacy of our education system disrupts our economic health, and will only progress if nothing changes. “School dropouts report unemployment rates as much as 40% higher than youth who have completed school. Arrest rates are alarming for youth with disabilities who drop out of school— 73% for students with emotional/behavioral disabilities and 62% for students with learning disabilities. More than 80% of individuals incarcerated are high school dropouts (Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, 1995)” (“Students with Disabilities who Drop Out of School—Implications for Policy and Practice”). As evidenced by statistics like these the question isn’t does public education need reform, but as Ken Robinson states in “Changing the Education Paradigms,” “how do we educate our children to take their place in the 21st century?” This at least should be clear: we cannot “meet the future by doing they what did in the past” (2). It’s time for change. For instance, our education system must become more inclusive by acknowledging intelligence and potential in all shapes and sizes. Our tendency to categorize people as either “academic or non-academic [has caused] many brilliant people to think they’re not because they’ve been judge by a particular view of the mind” (Robinson 2). We can all agree that we want to be acknowledged as individuals in