preview

Eras Of Security Development And Fragile States : The Evolution Of Canadian Policy

Better Essays

The readings this week focused on the development programs and assistance regarding fragile states. Most of the articles focused on different eras of security development and fragile states and practical examples such as Afghanistan while the last article, by Stephen Baranyi and Themrise Khan, stepped away from Afghanistan and focused on other fragile states. There were many themes this week, but the ones I want to address in my paper is the western centric approach to stability and security and the disconnect between policy and on ground action due to bureaucratic barriers to securitization. Though there were other themes present in the articles, these three stood out to me as being the most relevant. The article by Tom Keating, …show more content…

Keating suggests that, the United States identified failed states as its principal security threat. The similarity between the United States agenda and Ottawa’s action is presented by Janice Gross Stein and Eugene Lang in “The 3Ds in Afghanistan”. The author suggests that the most serious criticism of Canadian Forces is that, “the military was working with their friends in Washington to drive policy in the direction they wanted it to go.” Consequently, “the government has worried about security, when failed states represent a direct threat to Canadian [and western] interests.” Aside from the western interests in the eras described by Tom Keating, the goals of the security agenda is very western centric. Erin Simpson in “From Inter-Dependence to Conflation: Security and Development in the Post-9/11 Era”, lays out some of the end goals of security development for ODAs eligibility. The list Simpson provides includes democratic control of budgeting, management, accountability, and auditing of security expenditure, enhancement of civil society’s role, introduction of legislation to prevent recruitment of child soldiers, security reform to improve democratic governance and civilian control, and civilian activities for peace building. This list has a western democratic scope to it that perhaps is not culturally relevant in the region. Simpson concludes her work by saying that the states signed the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and

Get Access