preview

Essay On Who Fired First

Decent Essays

Who fired first in the historical Battle of Lexington? Well there is no right answer history has shown people have come up with theses trying to prove what had happened but we just really don’t know. But I think I have found the the answer. I believe the colonist fired first because they have a history of antagonizing the british in some situation’s it has turned deadly. Also on many accounts of the events they had been found guilty of firing first.My reasons to support my thesis are from British Lieutenant John Barker’s personal diary of the day of the event and George Leonard a colonist who wrote to British general to tell him what he experienced. My rebuttal sources are Simon Winship’s official deposition in which he claims that the …show more content…

My first rebuttal source is Simon Winships official deposition 6 days after the event. He claims that the british fired first when he says “The troops marched on till they came within a few rods of captain parkers company, who were partly collected on the place of the parade, when said winship observed an officer at the head of said troops flourishing his sword, and with a loud voice giving the word fire.” So what happened was he was on the front line when he claims to have seen the british fire first.But this is not a reliable source for the reason of it is 6 days after the event they may forget some stuff as if it was on the day of the event as both of my sources. Also then is it more reliable if a colonist say it was a colonist or a british claiming it was the colonist.

My final piece of rebuttal evidence is from the official deposition of Sylvanus Wood. He claims it was the british when he says “There was not a gun fired by any of Captain Parkers company within my knowledge”. So he was supposedly on the frontline with Captain Parker and they claimed that none not single person in their army fired birst But the flaw in

Get Access