preview

Euthanized Patients

Decent Essays
Open Document

Who should Euthanized patients?
I have argued that euthanasia is not medical treatment and therefore should not be administered by physicians. However, I have also acknowledged that terminally ill patients are entitled to be euthanized if they so desire. This then asks the question of who should aid in the process? Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act, which came into force in 1997, shows that euthanasia is possible without the direct involvement of physicians. The group Compassion and Choices has as a part of its mission, “authorize and implement medical aid in dying to allow mentally capable adults in their final weeks or months of a terminal disease to advance the time of death and end unbearable suffering” . The group works closely with physicians …show more content…

They formulate a hypothesis, the “Alexander Hypothesis”- stating that lawyers can be trusted more than physicians to act on the basis of the patient’s value rather than their own. They conclude that if this is true, the puzzle of not having physicians directly involved in ending a patient’s life has been solved. This ‘new’ practice is would be called legistrothanatry (Sade and Marshall). They argue that lawyers are more inclined to act in the interest of the patient, and euthanizing would not require sophisticated technical expertise so with a few training sessions, legistrothanatrists would be equipped to carry out their task. Margaret Brazier has also mentioned the use of thanatologist- ‘death bringer’ being responsible for the active role in euthanasia. Like the earlier proposal, both Sade and Marshall and Brazier propose divorcing the act of terminating the life of a terminally ill patient and medical …show more content…

While this is true, I remain steadfast in arguing that the end of medicine are health, cure, and care: making it incompatible with euthanasia. The killing of a patient ought not to be a goal of a physician-patient encounter. There is just no active participatory role for physicians in the death of a person- the professional ethic refuses to allow for intentional harm to be done to done to a

Get Access