Evaluating Qualitative Research In Nursing Care

Evidence-based practice has informed healthcare professionals to ask clinical questions and inform clinical practice (Rebar & Gersch, 2015, p. 11). The authors conducted an evidence-based research study to determine the effectiveness of telephone-based peer support (TBPS) for postpartum depression (PPD) up to two years after delivery. The primary goal for this paper is to synthesize and critically analyze the article. Therefore, nursing research knowledge is used to summarize and critique the article: problem and purpose; literature review; sampling; ethical considerations; research design; results and conclusion; and strengths and weaknesses.

Expertise is acquired through professional experience and is indicative of a nurse who has moved beyond mere proficiency. As Gadamer29 points out, experience involves a turning around of preconceived notions, preunderstandings, and extends or adds nuances to understanding. Dewey49 notes that experience requires a prepared “creature” and an enriched environment. The opportunity to reflect and narrate one’s experiential learning can clarify, extend, or even refute experiential learning.

In order for a healthcare system to run effectively, research is essential when patents are involved. According to Jones (2016), research involves a structured, planned and logical approach to discovering new information, while aiming to extend understanding on a topic or problem area within the healthcare profession. To achieve this, research is divided into two methodologies, qualitative and quantitative. Qualitative research involves methods that are concerned with human perceptions and understanding of their social reality, adopted under complex research topics (Washer, Salloch, Ritter, Vollmann, Schildmann, 2017). These are usually adapted when the exploration topic involves patient experiences, perceptions, meanings, intentions and behaviours (Jones, 2016). Whereas quantitative approaches aim to produce and control social phenomena, through measurement, evaluation and generalisation of findings of a population and encouraging the reproduction of the results obtained. These studies are based around testing hypotheses utilising patients to achieve research goals in controlled environments (Park & Park, 2016). This paper will explore the features of qualitative and quantitative research through papers involving patients in order to highlight the differences in their features, via the aim, data collection methods and results obtained. The quantitative paper explores the effect of muscle energy technique and passive stretching on patients with functional disability with

As a single descriptive study, this research study stands at the lower end of the continuum regarding strength of research evidence, however, this does not deem the findings useless. Although, the findings observed may not be immediately applied to clinical procedures and interventions it still brings light to a phenomenon within clinical practice. According to Grove et al. (2015) “descriptive studies often provide initial knowledge, which serves as a basis for generating quasi-experimental and outcomes studies” (p. 25). With the new insight gained through the study, future studies could be done to see if this finding could be manipulated and replicated to produce stronger

The authors relied heavily on two studies to create their argument. The first study mentioned was the Pinto et al article. In this study, "Pinto and colleagues (5) assessed the

The design of this study will be quasi-experimental, in that the standard elements of the studies mentioned before will be present in this proposal, but with the inclusion of a newer solution, that are being used in order to clean wounds and prevent infection from occurring once the wounds have been dressed with a novel silver dressing. This will include a solution that contains Manuka Honey in it (the active ingredients are not all known yet, only that a chemical reaction that takes place when exposed to a wound is the formation of benzoyl peroxide (Mandal and Mandal, 2011)), and covered/packed with Mepilex wound dressings. This will also serve as only a baseline sample — no combinations

The study by Reiner and Gearhart has a small sample, and so the results from this study may also be invalid.

Are the conclusions of the authors justified based on the findings? Do the authors describe the importance of this study to the field and does it fairly represent findings of the experiments?

Altarum will conduct a set of qualitative research interviews with a panel of 15 payer or resource optimization experts that are representative of all sectors in healthcare. In terms of health services delivery, it has been highlighted that one set standard of rules for reducing low value care overuse depends greatly the how providers define the term and assess their options. In efforts to effectively influence guidelines in cost sharing, policy and value based payments, it is necessary to grasp the crux of low value care measures from a grouping of expert providers. With an emphasis placed on the designation of low care value practice attribution and evidence based practice, a wide array of

When writing in Nursing, I know that data and research are key components. By making charts, such as flow charts or medical charts and effective research is used including nursing notes and lab reports. When writing research papers, form a credible research question followed by a conclusion based on legitimate source. Arguments essays should be taken from a controversial stance and backed up with up-to-date research. With reviews, narratives, and reflections, client history, diagnosis, treatment, data analysis, and a summary of findings should all be included in the writing. Along with research, evidence of measured data, behavior reports, lab tests results, and experimentation are to be well detailed and clear.

PRESENTATION: The report was well written, flowed logically, and was written in enough detail for critical analysis the description of finding was rich and powerful.

Null Hypothesis: Medical honey is not an effective agent in fighting bacterial growth in wounds.

If you look up the term ‘nurse practitioner’ in the dictionary, it will read, “a nurse who is qualified to treat certain medical conditions without the direct supervision of a doctor”. However, the role of nurses in healthcare is not limited to the treatment of medical conditions. Florence Nightingale, the founder of modern nursing, once said, “Nursing is an art: and if it is to be made an art, it requires an exclusive devotion as hard a preparation, as any painter’s or sculptor’s work; for what is the having to do with dead canvas

From explaining to the primary care physician what procedure they are considering to simply being able to cross examine those that may be trying to scam them, research is a vital instrument for the patient to possess. Through the research process people will come across sources which are biased, false, don’t have enough proof to back up their facts, etc. It is very important to be able to recognize which resources are reliable and which may contain misinformation as false facts lead to unpleasantries such as miscommunication, possible injury to self through introduction to scammers or non licensed practitioners who have no permission to perform on the client, problems with your primary care, as well as having the potential to create a problem

My initial response to this article is that it presents interesting information. It also brought along the question of: Who sponsored this research? As I am aware that depending on the sponsor information in studies can be skewed. I can neither agree nor reject these findings, as I do not know enough about this subject as of present.