preview

Evaluation Of The Alternative Of Economic Progress

Better Essays

Ashley Beckett 11138895 Geography 280 Bert Weichel and Rod Johnson September 18, 2015 Evaluation of the Alternatives to GDP in the Measuring of Economic Progress Measuring the success of a country in modern society is very important as it influences future decisions made to improve economy. The main indicator used to measure a country’s success is the Gross Domestic Product (GDP). GDP represents the total dollar value of all goods and services produced, usually annually. Just like all indicators, GDP has several limitations and may not be the best-suited indicator for sustainable success. In calculating a country’s success, GDP only includes the benefits of economic growth, such as production and consumption of goods, and not the …show more content…

Because it considers the negative effects on the environment and inequality of expenses among people, ISEW is a more balanced index and can be better sustained in the environment while the economy continues to grow. The Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI) and ISEW are very similar. In fact they are often grouped together in discussion because both ISEW and GPI suggest that the costs of economic growth outweigh the benefits, and this will ultimately lead to uneconomic and unsustainable growth (paraphrasing Herman Daly) (Van den Bergh and Antal 2014, 4). Although these two indicators share multiple features, GPI incorporates additional elements such as crime, divorce, unemployment and changes in leisure time. “Furthermore, GPI is considered less complex and more accessible to all people” (Schepelmann, Goossens, and Makipaa 2010, 25). This simplicity makes it appealing to the general public. A country’s economic success includes happiness, which depends on leisure time (Van den Bergh and Antal 2014, 5). Since GPI is based on personal consumption and expenditure, it includes hobbies and leisurely activities in calculations. Decrease in consumption of resources and work hours both lead to a less stressful life and provides more personal time for individuals and their families. This correlates with GPI’s goal of growth of the economy with lower overall consumption rates. Nevertheless this result is not flawless, as people with more money and time are likely

Get Access