Evil in Byron's Dramas: Manfred, Cain, Heaven and Earth, The Deformed Transformed.
The depictions of and ideas about evil in Byron's dramas Cain, The Deformed Transformed, Heaven and Earth and Manfred are fairly common between the four texts. On the basic level, evil is seen as a force opposite to good, which all humans have the potential for. Only some humans express this potential, and their downfall into evil is often brought about by temptation, usually from a divine being. God punishes evil. This interpretation of evil is problematic, however. Because God administers punishment, evil becomes anything that questions the omnipotence of God. The hint that God himself may have an evil side is a truth …show more content…
On Cain's return from his experience with Lucifer, he describes to Adah the conclusions he has come to about God and the nature of evil. Simply from these words, not from any sinful deed Cain does, Adah is able to conclude that "Thy guide hath done thee evil" (Cain Act III). His "sin" here is merely questioning why he should suffer for his parent's crimes. Japhet's only sin is to question why the Sons of Cain cannot be saved, yet he is admonished by Noah for this sin - "with thy tongue/ Do God no wrong!/ Live as he wills it - die, when he ordains" (Heaven and Earth Act I Scene III). Noah sees God as so far above and controlling of humanity that for him to change his will "for a mere mortal sorrow" would be "a sin".
Evil has also to do with over-ambition and pride. Cain is rebuked by Lucifer for wanting to know too much - "Dust! Limit thy ambition!" Noah entreats Japhet not to question the Divine will. Manfred's punishment continues because of his pride, as he refuses to accept the help of the Witch of the Alps.
Despite this hubristic idea of evil as humans overreaching their natural boundaries, there is no punishment
Lord Byron's Manfred Essay2351 Words | 10 Pages
Lord Byron's Manfred George Gordon, otherwise known as Lord Byron, was the most controversial poet of his time. As one of the “second-generation” romantics, Byron fused together high romance with a love of nature and tragic loss. He virtually invented the idea of romantic irony, or the idea of the hero as a tragic figure who is born to “desire a transcendence that can never be achieved” (Hogle, March 21 Lecture). Byron perfected this technique through the creation of what is…
Interpreting Lord Byron's Manfred Essay874 Words | 4 Pages
Lord Byron's Manfred is a dramatic poem that can be interpreted in many ways. Manfred is clearly distraught throughout the play, and it appears to be because of the death of his sister and lover Astarte. It is only hinted, which allows the reader to imagine how Manfred is really reacting, down to his emotions and facial expressions. In Act 2, Scene 2, Manfred makes his most revealing statement. He has spoken to many different supernatural creatures since the beginning of the play. In the middle…
Heaven Is A Place On Earth861 Words | 4 Pages
Heaven is a Place on Earth Growing up a Christian I have no perspective of what it is like not to know who God is. To be able to relay what I know is harder than knowing what I know. Those who do not know who God is and do not have an understanding of Christianity often look at Christians as judgmental, self-righteous, and hypocritical. I cannot say they are entirely wrong in their thinking, however; when explaining the Christian Story you need to make sure you do not affirm their thinking. The…
Byron's Depression Reflected in Manfred Essay1944 Words | 8 Pages
Byron's Swiss tour and Manfred hit close to home for me. Not because I have traveled Switzerland, but because at one time in my life, I also experienced feelings of alienation and hopelessness. Therefore, I was quite intrigued by Dr Miall's notion of trauma in Manfred. I think he makes a compelling argument, especially when he pairs the notion of trauma with Freud's theory on the causes of trauma, but I do not necessarily agree with him entirely. While Dr Miall's theory is sound, I do not think…
The Link Between Earth And Heaven1278 Words | 6 Pages
Kingship—Linking Heaven and Earth: Try to imagine these three distinct situations: The year is 1124 B.C.E and in China, the Zhou dynasty has recently prevailed over the largely successful Shang Empire. Just years earlier in approximately 3100 B.C.E, near the smooth flowing Nile, a conqueror by the name of Menes (Narmer) was in the process of establishing a centralized state which was to be ruled by the supreme pharaoh. Back in “the land between the two rivers”, Babylonian ruler King Hammurabi was…
The Counsel Of Heaven On Earth1596 Words | 7 Pages