preview

Examples Of Antigone's Duty

Good Essays

Thomas More refuses Henry’s command to take the oath because it violates his conscience. He defines his conscience and morality by two main duties, one to God and a lesser one to the law. By putting King Henry at the head of the church, the oath violates his duty to both. The Pope is the rightful head of the Church as the descendant of St. Peter, so the oath is “directly repugnant to the law of God and His Holy Church, the supreme government,” and More cannot take it (A Man for All Seasons). He also has a duty to his kingdom and the civil laws that govern it, which is secondary to his duty to God (he states that he is God’s servant before he is the King’s). More states that the Magna Carta and Coronation Oath guarantee the Catholic Church’s authority over the King, which the oath obviously contradicts. Thus, More believes that taking …show more content…

Similar to More, Antigone has religious transcendent interests motivating her refusal of government orders. They both believe their religious duties are greater than their duties to the state, and that any divine punishment would be much worse than the state’s punishment. More’s religious duties are tied up in his conscience; Antigone’s are more purely about obeying what she believes is her duty to God. Antigone has an additional transcendent interest in her loyalty to her family – she is fiercely loyal to her brother and preserving his afterlife. More isn’t forced to choose between family and self-interest, as is Antigone. Though he wants to protect his family, his refusal concerns only his own conscience and afterlife. Also, Antigone directly disobeys Creon’s orders by burying her brother; she makes it clear that she does not agree with Creon. More simply stays silent on the matter until right before he dies. He also actively avoids disobedience, even stepping down from his position to avoid taking the first

Get Access