Oscar Wilde states that, “It is through disobedience that progress has been made, through disobedience and through rebellion.”. Many people, and it does not matter what kind of person they are, go through disobedience. It is something that they cannot get out from because it is in everyday of our lives. Wilde explains that this can give progress to some factors in life, and am sure that it can be used for the good. When people are are disobedient, they can learn from their bad habits that they created, but also can see there is good progress that came out of it. Disobedience and rebellion are traits that nobody likes in some people. Reason is because the people who have these traits tend to act out of control or over use their power. For example, both traits had many roles in wars because some soldiers did not listen to their captains because they wanted to attack their own way. What comes out of it sometimes is progress, which is a good thing to happen especially in their type of situation. It plays as a large valuable trait that us humans hold. …show more content…
In the book, “The Great Gatsby”, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, a character in the book named Daisy goes through these traits of being disobedient and rebellious. This trait helps Daisy to find out what she really wants in life, her husband or her first true loves. She plays around to see which is right for her but when chaos begins and the man Daisy was having an affair with died. The disobedience that Daisy was giving of made a big situation which caused one that she leaves to die, but did give her progress in life by now not know who she really
The author exemplifies the ways that disobedience helps the society and its contribution to furthering the human race but notes on the fact that blind obedience may eventually account for the end of civilization.
Irish author Oscar Wilde offers up the idea that we as humans are fundamentally made to disobey, as this trait may also lead to great progress in our society. In this way, Wilde is correct in his assertion that disobedience promotes great, positive change, as seen throughout history, despite some instances where disobedience is simply violence and does not directly correlate to any positive change. For one, a prime example
The idea that disobedience promotes social progress is valid because there is a saying that says “we learn from our mistakes” so through the trouble people make, they learn and grow from that situation. For instance, in schools, many students face tests that did not study for and fail it, but later they try to study again to do better the next time. Hardship opens the mind to a different perspective which also means people would rebel to give them a different meaning in their life. This mentality creates a sense of hope and pride that makes people want to do better or try to progress from that mistake. Most people like a challenge which helps encourage them to work harder and help them to realize that there is always a way to finding a better
Human beings possess several virtues that differentiate them from other creatures and can use them in ways that represent their perceptions of social order. Surprisingly, Oscar Wilde believes that disobedience is an original virtue of every human and that it is responsible for progress and development. While Wilde’s claim is not entirely accurate, it is largely valid as evidenced by the recent events across the world, including the US, that have led to positive outcomes in spite of being termed and perceived as acts of disobedience.
When someone hears the word disobedience it usually leads to the thought of misbehaving for the wrong reasons. For some people disobedience is an act of freedom, for some it releases them from what has always been so they can live lives they have always imagined. Erich Fromm makes thought-provoking points in his book “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem”. He talks about the concept of Disobedience with religion as well as touching base with different kinds of obedience to power, and his thoughts on what freedom is through the act of disobedience. Many of his thoughts were directed towards religion but may be interpreted in different ways. Disobedience is going to happen, the younger individuals are when they test limits the better because the stakes are not high.
In the novel Daisy forces herself to be conformed into the frame of society. Daisy’s true love, Gatsby is what started the beginning of
If disobediance is used in very wrong or profounded way then it can be wrong to go against bc its all about your response you give to be going against and it has to be proper cause that you fell should be different.So for that trait to be useful is very much true.Like going back to martin luther king he went against the ways of the world and showed that it should be different for him and others so having that disobediance trait is what helped him acomplished what he wanted to point out in the world.Its that segregations of colors is wrong and tha all people are made eqaul.
Gatsby does not belong to his own class and he is not accepted by the upper class, therefore he becomes an exception. Because of disappointment of being looked down upon and impossibility of accept by the upper class, he has nothing left except his love, which is also his “love dream”. Gatsby’s love for Daisy has been the sole drive and motive of his living. Gatsby’s great love is also the root of his great tragedy, because he is desperately in love with a woman who is not worthy of his deep love. Fitzgerald offers Gatsby with the spirit of sincerity, generosity, nobility, perseverance, and loyalty. All his good natures can be seen
Disobedience is a virtue When disobedience occurs, society feels threatened, but only a few have the heart and courage to encourage it. Oscar Wilde’s claim is that “disobedience is a valuable human trait and that it promotes social progress.” Although many oppose his claim Wilde is right because disobedience can improve a situation or help with social issues.
Wilde states that we as humans progress with disobedience. To many it seems to be true, but Wildes claim isn't truthful, there are many ways to make a change it doesn't necessarily have to be through disobedience, it seems like we are but that's based on eachothers standpoint.
In the book The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, Daisy Buchanan plays a significant role as a mother, wife, and lover to another man. Before her marriage with Tom at age nineteen, Daisy fell in love with Gatsby and was left heartbroken when he did not return from war. Her mother ended up forcing her into her marriage with Tom because Daisy received a letter from Gatsby and realized she still had feelings for him and did not want to marry Tom. Daisy went on to give birth to her daughter Pammy and although struggling with her relationship with Tom, she still wants to stay with him for the sake of her family and their image. Throughout the book, The Great Gatsby, Daisy demonstrates how she is discouraged, indecisive, and cowardly through
Overall, disobedience can affect several people in general, or only themselves in different ways. Also it can improve in social progress or make it weaker. The meaning of disobedience isn’t all about failure, or not following the rules. It can also be something positive, and it can lead you into having faith in yourself.
What good can come of disobedience? Many have asked—especially those who’ve been obedient their entire life. Since the time our foot has entered kindergarten, everyone was taught to be respectful and usually, that meant being compliant to our teachers. Being obedient was engraved into our heads at a very young age and that it'll lead us to a better future. Can we honestly say it's our future that we are leading? We'll grow up being a sheep of mankind, and that's why being disobedient is crucial in life. Disobedience allows for society to progress because it generates a better future, promotes individualism, and changes how people view controversial subjects.
We've all thought about rebelling or disobeying at least once throughout our lives. It's just how we as humans work. If we see something we don't believe in; we will stand up for it. Irish Oscar Wilde had said the reason we've made progress was and is because we have rebelled. I agree with his statement, because if not for rebellion or disobedience, the United States of America would’ve never became a nation. People wouldn’t be free of past government laws. Women wouldn't have the rights they have today without some sort of action. Although we have the right of free speech today, before it wasn’t considered a right of the people. It was an act of rebellion against the government.
As we set out in the world for the first time, we are starting to understand the world around us is flawed. Most people are shielded during their childhood in order to protect their innocence, but as we go out into the real world we need to understand that people defy the rules of society. There is a large difference between disobeying the laws that every citizen must abide by and standing up to a cause we believe in. Disobedience is important to the progression of the world around us, but there are different types of disobedience. There is the disobedience that has a positive effect, such as people peacefully protesting for what they believe in and fighting for a change. There is also disobedience that has a negative effect, such as people breaking the rules for the fun of it. Disobedience is because it is necessary for social progress, saves lives, and starts a conversation about difficult subjects. However, it can also cause conflict.