preview

Examples Of Judgement In Cathedral

Decent Essays
Open Document

Trey Hurley Mrs. Lawrence DC English III, Period 3 15 April 2024 Essay #4: Judgment In “Cathedral” by Raymond Carver and “Big Jesse, Little Jesse” by Oscar Casares, both short stories have a common theme of judgment. For example, in “Cathedral” the blind man named Robert is judged by the narrator before he arrives at the narrator's and the narrator's wife's house. Judgment is also demonstrated in “Big Jesse, Little Jesse” when Big Jesse internally judges his child for not being like a normal kid and wanting his kid to be just like everyone else and how he was as a kid. In a TED Talk by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, she talks about what had happened throughout her life mainly knowing one side of the story, and reflects on the danger of one side …show more content…

Another example is when Robert is sitting down at the table with the narrator and his wife, and the narrator notices his eyes and how they “seemed to move around in the sockets without his knowing or being able to stop it,” and he judges his eyes and calls them “creepy” (Carver 216). Next, in “Big Jesse, Little Jesse,” Big Jesse is noticed as being judgmental to his son Little Jesse. Big Jesse judges Little Jesse because “he has no interest in playing outside,” despite them having a park right down the street from them, Big Jesse wishes that Little Jesse could be a little more normal and become friends with other kids in the neighborhood (Casares 90). Both stories have the comparison of being judgmental towards the different disabilities; however, in “Big Jesse, Little Jesse,” Big Jesse tones it down a little bit and doesn't judge his son as much as the narrator judges Robert in “Cathedral”. Both “Cathedral” and “Big Jesse, Little Jesse,” use sympathy to enlarge the motivations of the characters, yet the sympathy brings the real side of the characters out and causes them to rethink their

Get Access