Falsely Accused: A Defense of the Death Penalty Essay

2368 Words10 Pages
Gary Leon Ridgway may not be a household name, but the infamous Green River Killer is one of the most accomplished serial murderers in U.S. history. In 2003, Ridgway confessed 48 accounts of aggravated first degree murder (more confirmed murders than any other American serial killer) during a two-and-a-half-year period in the early 1980s near Seattle, although it is believed he slaughtered even more. The majority of his victims were runaway teenage girls and hookers whom he picked up on the interstate and strangled to death. But Ridgway was spared the death penalty as part of a plea bargain three years ago, in exchange for his assistance in leading investigators to his victim's remains and revealing other information to help "bring…show more content…
We no longer live in a Nuremberg Trial-era where a man can be hanged in the town square by an angry mob when suspected of ogling the Sherriff's daughter. Suspects are innocent until proven guilty, and the law requires the prosecution to bear the intricate burden of proof beyond all reasonable doubt for conviction - which does not, in and of itself, beget the death penalty. Only around one percent of convicted murderers are sentenced to death, and even fewer are actually executed (Death Penalty Information Center). The majority of the above exonerations have eventuated on political grounds - such as a request by the Pope, (Bill Clinton's) presidential pardons, and so on - not necessarily because evidence emerged of the inmate's innocence. Nevertheless, no human process boasts perfection, including that of law enforcement in general; and the potential shortcomings of the death penalty are worthy of acknowledgement. So long as we engage flesh-and-blood judges and jurors, occasionally unsound conclusions may be drawn, inaccurate interpretations or presentations may be conveyed, and wrong decisions may be realized. But to eradicate the system entirely as the solution to this inherent risk is as absurd a proposal as eliminating prisons because the possibility exists of wrongly incarcerating someone. Regardless of to what extent any legal structure may evolve, periodically - although rarely - an innocent man will be
Open Document