preview

Similarities Between Coaching And Feedback

Better Essays

Feedback versus Coaching: Same or Different? There are similarities between feedback and coaching, and in fact feedback is a part of coaching. Feedback on its own may seem to be a much shorter process of giving comments or advice about something that has or has not happened, and usually ends by someone making suggestions or asking how it could be done better. Coaching adds to feedback by providing a process for change, adding support for commitment to action. How to Provide Feedback Effectively Giving and receiving feedback has long been considered to be an essential skill for managers and leaders. Employees need to know how they are doing as they strive to achieve their organisation’s goals. They need to know how they are doing, whether the performance is up to standard, and if not, how they can improve. When improvement is needed, The S/TAR concept provides an effective method for providing feedback about the behaviour or results observed. The approach should also include suggestions or prompts towards how to handle the situation in the future. For example, let’s say you observed an employee refusing a request from another department. You could use the STAR concept to provide feedback on what you …show more content…

Managers then meet to recalibrate and gain final agreement on performance levels; this becomes a bun fight, and many of those rated at ‘exceeds’ level are reappraised at ‘meets’, which can be discouraging. The idea that five people in a work group could all be performing equally, but must be ranked from one to five in order to divide up compensation dollars, seems unfair. In fact, many employees cite informal, forced ranking as their major source of frustration with their organisation’s performance management system. This approach often results in fostering competitive rather than collaborative

Get Access