preview

Feminism, the Public and the Private Essay

Better Essays

Feminism, the Public and the Private

Conceptualizations of the public and the private have always been central to the politics of second-wave feminism. The slogan, "the personal is political," implied that private life was often the site, if not the cause, of women's oppression. In 1974, some of the authors of Woman, Culture and Society (Lamphere and Rosaldo 1974), one of the founding texts of academic feminism, asserted that the universal cause of women's oppression lay in their confinement to the domestic sphere. Since that time, anthropologists have modified and complicated their assertions about the private. 1 Many other scholars have turned to confronting the meaning of the public. Joan Landes's anthology represents an important …show more content…

Benhabib rejects both Arendt's agonistic republicanism and liberalism in favor of Habermas's radically procedural approach, which, she contends, offers a way to contest the rigid distinctions Habermas posed between public and private, justice and the good life, norms and values, and needs and interests.

The analysis of Habermas continues in Part II, "Gender in the Modern Liberal Public Sphere," which deals with the history of the public sphere from the Enlightenment through the establishment of what Carol Pateman calls in her essay, "The Patriarchal Welfare State." In "The Public and Private Sphere: A Feminist Reconsideration," Landes criticizes Habermas's universalizing and textualizing tendency. Like several other authors in this volume, Landes calls for a conception of the public that includes embodiment, iconicity, theatricality, [End Page 179] unruliness, affectivity, and particularity as well as the Habermasian rational discourse that masks its origin and interests as universality.

Lenore Davidoff is less interested in criticizing political theory than in showing how historians and others must look carefully at the ragged edges of the public, the semi-public, and the private spheres to understand how Victorian women and men of a variety of social classes came to define others and themselves in terms of rationality, individuality, the market, and property. Temporal and contested as these boundaries were, however,

Get Access