preview

Feminist Theory - There is No One Definition of Woman Essay

Better Essays

Feminist Theory - There is No One Definition of Woman

When posed with the question “What is woman?” it seems a daunting task to lay an umbrella statement to describe an entire gender. Upon further reflection, however, it seems that this overwhelming inability to answer the question, may in fact, be the answer to the question itself. Within the past two decades Maria Lugones and Elizabeth Spelman, Caroline Whitbeck, Geraldine Finn, and Helene Cixous have addressed the meaning of woman. There is not a concrete answer to “What is woman?” either produced by women or produced through men’s perceptions of women.

The message of Lugones and Spelman in Have We Got a Theory for You! Feminist Theory, Cultural …show more content…

Only then can we engage in mutual dialogue that does not reduce each one of us to instances of the abstraction called woman. (Ibid. 30)

Thus, Lugones and Spelman are advocating that it is not possible, nor necessary, to establish one sense of woman, but rather, to open the lines of communication between all women so that feminism is not hindered by a division in the ranks.

It is again seen in Theories of Sex Difference, that the author, Whitbeck, makes no attempt to establish one definition of woman. Whitbeck examines how philosophers have historically examined and thus defined women from the male perspective as either a partial man or as the second aspect of opposite principles[1][1] (35). Finn’s On the Oppression of Women in Philosophy – Or, Whatever Happened to Objectivity? contains a syllogism that demonstrates that philosophy’s omission of women:

Man is a rational animal à Sophia is a man à Sophia is a rational animal (157)

The second premises is completely false, “for replacing male terms by female terms changes the meaning of the paradigm or demonstration. It is in this way that women are ‘ignored’ … i.e. oppressed, in the very activity of philosophy” (Finn 157). Women’s cameos in philosophy

Get Access