preview

Flannery O Connor Analysis

Good Essays

The obscure religious agenda in J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series, supported by that of J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis, is akin to that found in Flannery O'Connor's works. This similarity allows for the identification of Rowling as the O'Connor of this generation. Three main elements influence both Rowling and O’Connor’s works respectively. Religious background, writing as a means to spread the gospel, and a specified and intended audience are shared components and are essential to the crediting of Rowling as this generation’s O’Connor. Religious background acts as a commonality for the two authors. While the two authors belonged to different denominations (O’Connor devotedly Catholic and Rowling Presbyterian), religion held substantial …show more content…

O’Connor states “’The true prophet is inspired by the Holy Ghost, not necessarily by the dominant religion of his region’” (95), which proves against Catholicism. This idea of the inspiration by the Holy Ghost almost directly coincides with the fundamental tenet of Pentecostal. This tenet signifies the importance of “the baptism of the Holy Ghost with the initial sign of speaking with other tongues as the Spirit gives the utterance” (United Pentecostal Church International). Again, this proves to be another example where O’Connor’s actions do not coincide with her catholic views. Due to this discrepancy between Catholicism and Pentecostalism, critics such as McMullen misinterpret discrepancy for writing against God. Kara Lynn Andersen states that many conservative Christian groups believe that “stories about witchcraft and the occult lead children to try out spells of their own or research Satanism or Wicca on the Internet…the books are therefore the tools of Satan placed in our world through Rowling to lead children astray” (7). Another critic, Leanne Simmons, states “Some conservative Christians have condemned the Harry Potter series, claiming that the stories lure children into witchcraft and contain a completely relative morality” (53). The Harry Potter author speaks to the accusation by fellow believers that she writes for Satan by stating “’I go to …show more content…

Milbank explains that in the “‘post Christian phase’, where there is a decline in institutionalised religion, fantasy seems to have the ability to give glimpses of the Gospel, allowing the story of Christ to ‘persist in the echo of the public value’” (2). Anastasia Apostolides and Johann-Albrecht Meylahn state “Tolkien, Lewis, and in a contemporary world, Rowling, use glimpses of the Gospel in their work to expose and challenge the effects of the dominant discourses of their societies that they see as fragmenting and hurting people’s identities and binding them to material things” (5). In the same article, it is later stated that “As the Harry Potter series has the Christ discourse threaded in its sacred story, it allows the reader glimpses of the values of the Gospels from an everyday perspective and that makes the series function as lived theology” (6). Also stated is the idea that, “Rowling’s wizarding ‘Sub-Creation’ gives a very similar choice to those of Lewis and Tolkien (the choice between Christ and corruption)” (5). While many conservative Christians jump to the assumption that with the storyline revolving around warlocks and wizardry the series must promote satanic values, the series as a whole follows an extremely Christ-like path. Rowling states, “to me [the religious parallels have] always been obvious…but I never wanted to talk too openly about it because I thought it might

Get Access