preview

Founding Brothers Analysis

Decent Essays

Throughout American history there are numerous stories of great compromises which change the course of historical events. Some of these stories do not accurately depict the essence of the compromise after it had been made. Knowledge of these stories uncover the questions of what effects and impacts do those compromises have after they run their course. Furthermore, how are these compromises reached. Joseph Ellis describes multiple compromises in his National Bestseller Founding Brothers and how simply but dramatically the compromises impact the young, growing nation and government. Looking back to 1804 historians are introduced to fairly unknown, but one of the most famous compromise between General Alexander Hamilton and Colonel …show more content…

Ellis describes the destination for the duel as “a popular spot for duels precisely because of its relative isolation and inaccessibility.”(23) The two men on the “popular spot” for a duel stood ten paces apart with both of their weapons. Since hamilton was challenged he chose the weapons; a pair of pistols decorated by his brother. Hamilton also had choice of where he wanted to stand. He stood upstream from Burr. Two shots rang out but only Hamilton was hit. Burr understood immediately that he struck Hamilton with a fatal shot and wanted to speak with him. Hamilton’s shot missed and hit the tree’s behind Burr. While Burr did not suffer from a fatal wound his reputation did. He became the “most despised nation leader since Benedict Arnold.” (38) After the duel came the consequences. Burr’s consequence, much like Hamilton’s was fairly obvious. However the nations consequence was a little more hidden. “The fate of the American experiment with the republican government still required virtuous leaders to survive.”(47) With both Hamilton and Burr out of the picture due to their actions regarding the duel, the “American experiment with the republican government” was put at risk. The government, as new as it was, did not have strong political leaders and was put in jeopardy going forward. Although through speculation, Historians concluded that both parties, Hamilton and Burr, had only attended the interview as a result of their wish to be considered a part of the virtuous leader company. Unfortunately their efforts were not viewed in the way they had intended and they butchered their own reputations. Their famous compromise threatened the future of the government despite their

Get Access