preview

Founding Brothers Essay

Decent Essays
Open Document

Who or what is the first thing that comes to mind when the word whiskey is mentioned? Jack Daniel’s or a fun Saturday night out? Perhaps, but most likely not the Whiskey Rebellion of 1791. This Rebellion resulted from the passage by Congress of an excise tax to be applied to distilled liquor and was led by Pennsylvania farmers. Occurring from 1791 to 1794, the Whiskey Rebellion ended when President Washington sent close to 13,000 soldiers to the relatively small area to stop the protesters.(Page 141) This event is a classic example of the struggle between States’ rights and Federal Authority, which Joseph J. Ellis illustrates in the book Founding Brothers. Even today, the battle of power continues between the States and the Federal Government …show more content…

The Republicans, led by Jefferson and Madison, were supporters of States’ rights. They believed that the American Revolution occurred to free America from British control and allow the creation of a country led by self-governing people. The Federalists, led by Washington and Hamilton, agreed that the American Revolution took place to free America, but asserted that the newly freed needed a strong central government to provide guidance. THe debate that occurred over Hamilton’s proposed assumption plan is another prime example of the seat of power dispute. Hamilton proposed the national government to assume all the states’ debt incurred from the American Revolution. “Hamilton regarded the national debt as “a national blessing,” for it permitted the clustering of resources in the hands of a small group of enterprising men who would invest and not just spend it.”(Page 64) Madison believed this plan to be unfair to the states, mostly southern, that had already paid back large sums of their respective debts. “The assumption proposal therefore did them an injustice, by “compelling them, after having done their duty, to contribute to those states who have not equally done their duty.””(Page 57) The resulting Assumption Bill that was approved by Congress was a compromise that provided the Republicans the assurance of fairly distributed debt and the Federals a source of

Get Access