preview

Franklin And Red Jacket Essay

Decent Essays

1.In my opinion, I strongly believe that the main idea behind the essays by both Franklin and Red Jacket is the major differences between Native Americans and white people. The only difference is that Franklin provides a point of view of the white person, while Red Jacket presents the issue by the eyes of the Native person. Issues of miscommunication prompted the Franklin’s writing, and the issue of religion prompted the speech of Red Jacket. Often, the topic of religion is highly connected and considered to be the root of the problem. The other topic that is being discussed is the deep cultural differences and communication difficulties. This issue is perfectly expressed by Franklin: “Savages we call them, because their Manners …show more content…

Thomas Plaine is making an argument about the American Independence. He starts his essay with covering general topics and giving us some background of the issue. After that, he explains the difference between society and the government. Then he proceeds to describe what would have happened if there were no American independence – he explains the attitude of England toward America as part of its territory. He provides numerous examples showing that America is better off on its own, and that the independent government with no king would give the country many more opportunities. That the rule of Britian will restrict the country in many ways starting from free trade and finishing with the possible threat and past examples of Britain attacking its colonies. He also offers a solution to this problem and suggest that each colony should have a voice in the government. I think the most persuasive part of his essay is not some certain argument (as there are many of those and they all make sense) but the way he structures his argument and provides information. I think he is taking an objective point of view and remains unbiased, which adds a lot of credibility to his arguments. For example, after discussing some issue Paine attempts to review other points of view as can be seen in this line: “As much hath been said of the advantages of reconciliation, which, like an agreeable dream, hath passed away and left us as we were, it is but right, that we should examine the contrary side of the argument…”. I think this essay is a great example of how argumentative essay should be

Get Access