preview

Genetic Enhancement and Politics Essays

Better Essays

Genetic Enhancement and Politics

Since the beginning of organized government there has always been a clash between science and politics. Whether it is as complicated as a new drug's detainment of federal approval or whether it is as commonplace as the social acceptance of a new medical procedure, politics has performed an integral part in the formation of science; this integrated unit is what greatly affects most of the society at large. Thus, it is no surprise the scientific discussion of genetic engineering is peppered with political rhetoric.

Before entering into a discussion of genetics and politics, a few scientific definitions are essential to fully understand the arguments which will be presented. First, …show more content…

Gene therapy is defined as the medical replacement of defective genes in living human cells; its aim is to replace the activity of a defective gene by activating a dormant gene which has a similar function (Wheale & McNally, 212). Under gene therapy comes the politically controversial Human Genome Project, a fifteen-year, $3 billion federally-funded biology program. The goal of the project is to isolate the defective gene on the chromosomes which comprise the human genome (Fletcher, 2). In this manner, the Human Genome Project may be able to rid the cancer-ridden genes from human DNA, thereby curing cancer permanently. The project has been the focus of much scientific and political controversy over the past few years for its possible ramifications are extensive to all of human existence.

Finally, genetic reductionism is the tendency to "stigmatize, ostracize or eliminate individuals or groups not meeting a genetic norm" (Butler, 369). Reductionism is the biggest threat to genome research and is the most explosive of the three genetic science discussed (gene engineering, therapy, and reductionism). Certain term such as "defective," "faulty," "advantage," and "genetic norm" plague the scientific discussion, thereby causing the very study of genetic manipulation to be political and controversial.

After

Get Access