preview

God's Omnipotence: The Paradox Of The Stone

Good Essays
Open Document

For centuries, philosophers, theists, and theologians alike have claimed that God is all-powerful. This is the divine attribute of God typically referred to as omnipotence. This attribute needs to be fleshed out, but, essentially, what this is saying is that God can do anything; however, is this true? There is an infamous paradox about God’s omnipotence that runs like this: If God is all-powerful, can he create a rock too heavy for him to lift? In either case, God cannot do something. Either God cannot create the rock or God can create the rock, but then cannot lift it. This puts the theist in a paradox. How can God do anything, yet not be able to do something?
The paradox of the stone, as this is famously dubbed, is far from novel. Answers have been engendered ever since Aquinas (Find Source), and continue to be so to this very day. Some have suggested that a better question to ask is whether or not God can limit His own power. Certainly, this is an important question and perhaps it can abate this conundrum, but maybe there is a different, more direct approach to the problem. After establishing a definition of Omnipotence and using that definition to critically analyze the notion of self-limitation and the …show more content…

Recall that the paradox of the stone is a question of whether or not God can create a stone too heavy for Him to lift. In light of Definition O, we want to know if it is logically possible for God to create said stone. From here, philosophers have rightly reduced the paradox to whether it is logically possible for God to limit his own power. If God can limit his own power, then it would seem plausible that he could create such a rock and then not have the ability to lift it. Self-limitation is paramount for understanding the paradox of the stone, but what exactly is self-limitation and is it the correct

Get Access