Great Wall Dbq

The Great wall cost them a lot of time and money. Document E states, during the period of the Qin they had people working on the wall for 10 whole years. That document also says many people died making the wall

The Great Wall of China was originally built during the Qin and Han Dynasties to protect China from the Xiongnu. It took the people of ancient China nearly 2,000 years to build and spans nearly 6,000 miles. However, building the wall was extremely costly in terms of men and supplies. Despite the cost of the wall, it proved to be immensely beneficial to the Chinese people. This is a result of the wall providing protection for merchants, the people within the wall and preventing the Xiongnu from invading.

For thousands years, the Mongols have been a big threat to the Chinese civilization. The Great Wall of China took about 2000 years to build and finish. It has been measured to be over 5,488 miles long. Due to the many threats and enemies of Chinese, the wall was built. In my opinion, the benefits of building the wall do outweigh the costs for many reasons surrounding the topic.

Should the Chinese have built Great Wall of China? It probably was not the best idea. When building the wall, they had three problems: The cost and the tribute to the Xiongnu Mongols, the high death rate, and the working conditions when building the wall. When the Chinese were building the Great Wall, they were faced with huge costs. Before they had the wall, they had to pay a tribute of Silk Floss(in catties) and Silk Fabric (in bales) to the Xiongu Mongols.

These walls were enormous projects which provided protection and glorified china. (Background Essay). The construction of the Great Wall of China was counterproductive due to innumerable casualties, paying tribute to the Xiongnu in valuable silk on top of having the wall, and causing poor, peasant families to get up

The Great Wall was built by The Qin and the Han Dynasty. They built The Great Wall to keep out and protect China from the Mongols. The benefits of building The Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs. In Document B, it showed that tribute was being paid by The Han. The Han was one of the the dynasties who first built The Great Wall. This shows that the benefits did not outweigh the costs because The Han still had tribute to pay to the Xiongnu Mongols and The Han dynasty still had to build and protect The Wall from the Mongols. In Document C, the text indicated that The Qin and The Han dynasties were peasants, and worked on The Great Wall while they got feed a little bit of food and suffered. The Qin and The Han were not treated well

The Great Wall of Ancient China: Did the Benefits Outweigh the Cost? The benefits of building a wall aren't outweighing the costs, According to Document C, "The Human Cost of the Great Wall", it states that Soldiers were forced to leave their families and villages for many years. This is important because it tells one of the struggles the soldiers had to go through.

If the wall were working than the Han would not have to bribe the Xiongnu to keep them away. The Han was losing money trying to bribe the Xiongnu because the wall was unsuccessful. The wall took years and years of time to build and this proves that those years were a waste. Although eh Han was bribing the Xiongnu, there was still a chance of a possible attack. The time and money spent on the wall was all put to a waste because the wall ended up being

There are three main reasons the benefits of building the Great Wall did not outweigh the costs 1.People Died 2. Lost of Resources 3. Tribute The first reason the benefits of the Wall did not outweigh the costs was because soldiers died because of hunger, sickness, or extreme heat or coldness. The soldiers were forced to work on the wall for 2 – 5 years.

It is a hard thought to swallow that a 13,170 mile wall that is visible from outer space and took over 2,000 years to entirely complete, was quite possibly not even worth it in the end. To this day, scientists, researchers, and intellectuals argue about whether or not the huge investment of time and money that the Chinese put forth was beneficial or a waste. The two early dynasties who forfeited these efforts were the Qin (221-206 BCE) and the Han (206 BCE-220 CE), and would most likely be devastated to find out that the project was a bit of a failure. Many scholars insist the result was not worth the cost for the reasons that the soldiers who guarded the wall faced extremities which prompted a large number of casualties, the cities inside faced starvation while building the wall, and although the wall gave some protection to this Chinese civilization, some invasions and threats still occurred. For these reasons, I

The Great Wall of China was built by the Qin and Han dynasties. The main reason they built this structure was to keep out the northern invaders, known as the Mongols. However, the benefits of the Great Wall did not outweigh the costs. For example, Document C shows many soldiers left their families, and their villages for several years. Also, millions of soldiers and workers died from coldness, and hunger. This means that more lives were taken than actually saved, which isn't fair. It isn't fair because everyone was in the army risking their lives to build the wall for it to not be worth it. The wall wasn't worth it because according to Document B, Han still had to pay

All major decisions have an effect on the economy. The Great Wall of China started circa 221 BCE. The wall has protected the whole of China from enemies ever since its completion in 206 BCE. The benefits of the Great Wall outweighed the costs because it protected China, made it more prosperous and united, and conveyed Chinese innovation.

The Great Wall of China is often regarded as one of the man made wonder of the world. The wall was built over a 2,000 year period. Such a big and sturdy Wall did not come cheap in terms of many people killed, a huge investment, and a lot of time spent working on the wall. Although the wall did serve many of its purposes, was it really worth the cost? There are three main reasons the construction of the wall did not outweigh the cost. Many died in the making, huge investment for china, did not keep invaders out.

This is a quote from a soldier guarding the walls perspective. “ We fight south of the wall, we die north of the wall” (Document F). The Great wall was constructed to keep out the invaders from north of China. The Great Wall of China was built in Asia, north of China. The chinese built it during the dynasties era. Was the Great wall worth building? The Great Wall of china was not worth building. It was not worth building, because it caused many deaths, tore families apart, and was not well constructed.

The Great Wall of China was built to protect China from invaders and to keep out raiding parties of nomadic tribes, such as the Mongol, Turic and Xiongnu, from modern-day Mongolia and Manchuria. The Mongols were a tribal group that would regularly raid China. The wall was successful in keeping the Mongols out of China for a while but eventually, the Mongols conquered China. The Wall also kept Chinese citizens from leaving China.