Great Wall Dbq

The first reason why the Great Wall was not worth the cost was because the wall was not very effective . The chin and Han dynasty's built the Great Wall to keep out invaders. People would walk around the spots where there wanot a wall built yet or a spot where guards were not on duty. ( Doc B ) The purpose was so that not as many guards would have to be on duty, but just as many guards were then as there were when the wall was not yet built. There were not guards protecting all spots of the wall, leaving it a blank opening for other enemies to enter. The wall was not just

The Great Wall of China was built to protect China from invaders and to keep out raiding parties of nomadic tribes, such as the Mongol, Turic and Xiongnu, from modern-day Mongolia and Manchuria. The Mongols were a tribal group that would regularly raid China. The wall was successful in keeping the Mongols out of China for a while but eventually, the Mongols conquered China. The Wall also kept Chinese citizens from leaving China.

The Great Wall was first build by Qin and Han.The reason why they build the wall is because to keep the enemies away like The Mongols.However, the benefits of the Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs.

The Great Wall of China is one of the most beautiful and biggest ancient structure. In ancient times it was very well maintained and now it is sort of maintained because 30% of the wall is gone. The wall shows pride and culture to china even though 30% of the wall is gone and now there are laws in place to protect and maintain the wall. However most of the wall if gone is from human damage.

This gave a sense of security to incoming traders from across the land. They felt safe to go beyond these walls and to trade inside. It also helped to increase the economy of China because of the increase of productivity and trade. The main purpose of the road was to protect trade on the silk road. This was the main location of where trade took place in China. The emperor even extended the wall to protect it far enough on the silk road. A China highlights website states that “In the Han Dynasty, the emperor's extended the Great Wall far into western’s China to protect the Silk Road trade” (Pkl). This proves how important it was for China to have these walls even it was at such a heavy

The Great Wall was built by The Qin and the Han Dynasty. They built The Great Wall to keep out and protect China from the Mongols. The benefits of building The Great Wall of China did not outweigh the costs. In Document B, it showed that tribute was being paid by The Han. The Han was one of the the dynasties who first built The Great Wall. This shows that the benefits did not outweigh the costs because The Han still had tribute to pay to the Xiongnu Mongols and The Han dynasty still had to build and protect The Wall from the Mongols. In Document C, the text indicated that The Qin and The Han dynasties were peasants, and worked on The Great Wall while they got feed a little bit of food and suffered. The Qin and The Han were not treated well

To begin with, the wall protected the people of China. The wall was comprised thousands of watchtowers and they had pulley systems for raising fire signals, according to the map on Document A. Chao Cou (document b), an advisor to multiple Han emperors, was highly respected for his ideas about military defense and border security, also had recommended building the wall to protect the Chinese people from a threat.

The Great Wall of Ancient China: Did the Benefits Outweigh the Cost? The benefits of building a wall aren't outweighing the costs, According to Document C, "The Human Cost of the Great Wall", it states that Soldiers were forced to leave their families and villages for many years. This is important because it tells one of the struggles the soldiers had to go through.

There are three main reasons the benefits of building the Great Wall did not outweigh the costs 1.People Died 2. Lost of Resources 3. Tribute The first reason the benefits of the Wall did not outweigh the costs was because soldiers died because of hunger, sickness, or extreme heat or coldness. The soldiers were forced to work on the wall for 2 – 5 years.

The Great wall cost them a lot of time and money. Document E states, during the period of the Qin they had people working on the wall for 10 whole years. That document also says many people died making the wall

The Great Wall of China was built by the Qin and Han dynasties. The main reason they built this structure was to keep out the northern invaders, known as the Mongols. However, the benefits of the Great Wall did not outweigh the costs. For example, Document C shows many soldiers left their families, and their villages for several years. Also, millions of soldiers and workers died from coldness, and hunger. This means that more lives were taken than actually saved, which isn't fair. It isn't fair because everyone was in the army risking their lives to build the wall for it to not be worth it. The wall wasn't worth it because according to Document B, Han still had to pay

If the wall were working than the Han would not have to bribe the Xiongnu to keep them away. The Han was losing money trying to bribe the Xiongnu because the wall was unsuccessful. The wall took years and years of time to build and this proves that those years were a waste. Although eh Han was bribing the Xiongnu, there was still a chance of a possible attack. The time and money spent on the wall was all put to a waste because the wall ended up being

A cruel emporer who sent his own people to die, for a wall which is just as protective as paper against fire, a wall that still couldn´t save the dynasty from falling. The Qin in 221 BCE and Han in 206 BCE commanded the construction of a grand wall using forced labor. They wanted to keep the Xiongnu who lived on chinaś northern border out and for good. They constructed this wall with hang’tu or pounded earth, by making a frame then pounding dirt in between the frame and finally removing the frame. After one dynasty fell the next restored and added to the wall.

According to document B, “People [slaves, convicts, and willing peasants] should be selected to settle along the border areas… while getting prepared against possible invasion by the Xiongnu.”(Document B). Since there were always people along the Great Wall it would be difficult for the Xiongnu to enter China and harm the people within the wall. Therefore, the wall provided a barrier that was both difficult to get around or climb and was also heavily guarded. Overall, the Great Wall offered the residents of China a strong sense of protection from

The Xiongnu, the Chinese’s most common enemy, would simply decide to ride around the wall or prompt traitors to open the gates for easy access (Laurisaar). Document C of the Great Wall Mini-Q also shows that the Han dynasty paid increasing tributes of silk thread and fabric to the Xiongnu most likely to keep them at bay. It can be inferred that the Mongols may have threatened the Han of invasion unless they willingly traded large amounts of silk. The chart makes it obvious that as time went on, their enemies pressed for more and more goods in order to agree to peace (“The Great”). If the wall was successful in keeping enemies out, the Chinese inside would not be wary of invasions because they would be protected. However, the information above proves that the wall failed at its job of protecting the citizens and I therefore believe the effort was not worth the